The Nahj al-balaghah is a collection of sermons, precepts, prayers, epistles and aphorisms of 'Ali ('a) compiled by al-Sayyid al-Sharif al-Radi about one thousand years ago. However, neither the recorded words of Mawla 'Ali are confined to those collected by al-Sayyid al-Radi, nor was he the only man to compile the sayings of Amir al-Muminin. Al-Masudi, who lived a hundred years before al-Sayyid al-Radi, in the second volume of his work Muruj al-dhahab , writes: "At present there are over 480 sermons of 'Ali in the hands of the people," whereas the total number of sermons included by al-Sayyid al-Radi in his collection is 239 only.
The alienation from the Nahj al-balaghah was not confined to me or others like me, but pervaded through the Islamic society. Those who understood this book, their knowledge did not go beyond the translation of its words and explanatory notes on its sentences. The spirit and the content of the book were hidden from the eyes of all. Only lately, it may be said, the Islamic world has begun to explore the Nahj al-balaghah , or in other words, the Nahj al-balaghah has started its conquest of the Muslim world.
What is surprising is that a part of the contents of the Nahj al-balaghah , both in Shi'ite Iran and Arab countries, was first discovered either by atheists or non-Muslim theists, who revealed the greatness of the book to the Muslims. Of course, the purpose of most or all of them was to utilize the Nahj al-balaghah of 'Ali ('a) for justifying and confirming their own social views; but the outcome was exactly opposite of what they desired. Because, for the first time the Muslims realized that the views expressed grandiloquently by others had nothing new to offer and that they cannot surpass what is said in the Nahj al-balaghah of 'Ali ('a), or translated into action through the character ( sirah ) of 'Ali and his disciples like Salman al-Farsi, Abu Dharr, and 'Ammar. The result of it was that instead of supporting the pretentious views of those who wished to exploit the Nahj al-balaghah , 'Ali and his book defeated their purpose. Nevertheless, it must be accepted that before this occurred, most of us had little knowledge of the Nahj al-balaghah and it hardly went beyond appreciation of few sermons about virtues of piety and abstinence. Nobody had yet recognized the significance of the valuable epistle of Mawla 'Ali to Malik al-'Ashtar al-Nakh'i; nobody had paid attention to it.
Addressee's of Nahjul Balagha
Imam Ali(a.s) in his sermons addressed several categories and groups of people both in positive and negative sense, we have summarized the groups over here:
His Ahlulbayt (a.s) - Preachings , Guidance
and Will
His sincere followers (a.s) - Guidance Advices (like Hamam, Meesam,
Malik-e-Ashtar)
First Group of Opponents, the Mushrikeen (infidels, Jews)
Second Group of Opponents, those companion of Prophet(s.w) who opposed him.
Third Group of Opponents , those companion of Prophet(s.w) who did not oppose
directly but remained silent when injustice was done to him and Islam.
Fourth Group, the opponents of Battle of Jamal
Fifth Group, the opponents of Siffeen (the companions of Muwiyah)
Sixth Group, the opponents of Naharwan (the Khwarij who deviated from him)
Seventh Group, his own followers who lacked the sense of responsibilty and were
condemned by him on several occassions in very harsh language (the Kufis)
The Contents of Nahjul
Balagha
Nahj al-balaghah comprises various issues
that cover major problems of metaphysics, theology, fiqh, tafsir, hadith,
prophetology, imamate, ethics,social philosophy, history, politics,
administration, civics, science, rhetoric, poetry, literature, etc. Most of the
discussions about various theological issues and philosophical notions in Islam
have their origin in this very book. Similarly, all the controversies regarding
socio-political problems in the Muslim society and state left their echo in
Nahj al-balaghah,or rather those were inspired from the utterances of al-lmam
'Ali (as). The book not only reflects the spirit of early Islam and the
teachings of the Quran and the Prophet (saw) in the proper perspective, but
also serves as a guide to traverse the future in the light of these teachings.
It is a matter of regret that Nahj al-balaghah was not properly utilized by the
Muslims as a source book of Islamic philosophy, kalam, fiqh, and ethics due to
misconceptions about its attribution to al-Imam'Ali (as) In the presence of
strong and sufficient evidence in support of the contents of the book being
authentic, it was sheer prejudice and lack of the spirit of inquiry that was
responsible for neglecting such a reliable source of Islamic ideas. In recent
times, the Orientalists have spread the unfounded doubts of Ibn Khallikan and
al-Dhahabi among Muslim and non-Muslim scholars in the name of objectivity in
research, thus giving a respectable appearance to their ignorance, which was,
of course, combined and prompted by their motive to ali enate the Muslims from
their intellectual heritage. I know many a scholar in India and Pakistan
questioning the authenticity of Nahj al-balaghah's ascription to Amir
al-Mu'minin using lofty words of research-objectivity with a hefty-pose of a
dispassionate seeker of truth. None of them, I am sure, ever studied any book about
early sources of the sermons and letters of al-'Imam 'Ali (as), nor did any one
of them ever try to gain really objective information about the book.
Unfortunately none of them bothered to go through even the valuable research
done by Imtiyaz 'Ali Khan 'Arshi, a widely read and respected writer in the
literary circles of Urdu in the Subcontinent. It was because of my first-hand
knowledge of this pitiable situation that I have intentionally devoted the
major part of the present article to the issue of the authenticity of the
attribution of the contents of Nahj al-Balaghah, in the light of earlier
sources, to 'Ali (as). Those who insist upon denying the veracity of Nahj
al-balaghah are either suffering from a malady of deep-rooted prejudice spread
through the propaganda of the supporters of Banu Umayyah, or their minds and
spirits have been blinded by the propagation of falsehood by the Orientalists
under the garb of high-sounding academic jargon. If our minds are cured of this
jaundiced perception of our own past, Nahj al-balagha can be paid the attention
it deserves and its contents will be studied and its meanings will be fully
explored and exploited for a better understanding of Islamic ideas and
realities. A look at the subjects discussed in Nahj al-balagha will be helpful
in ascertaining the wide scope of this invaluable treasure of wisdom. So far a
few attempts to classify the subject matter of the book have been made none of
which has been comprehensive. A subject-wise index of the contents of Nahj al-balaghah
has been prepared by 'Ali Ansariyan and published in Arabic under the title
al-Dallil 'ala mawdu'at Nahj al-balaghah in 1395/1975. It was translated and
published three years ago in Persian with the sub-title Nahj al-balaghah
mawdu'i. The compiler has divided the contents into eight categories, each
dealing with a specific subject further divided into various issues pertaining
to the main theme.
The main divisions are as follows:
1. Ma'rifat Allah,
2. Ma'rifat al-kawn,
3. Ma'rifat al-hujjah,
4. Ma'rifat nizam al-huqumah wa al-mujtama',
5. Ma'rifat al-'ahkam,
6. Ma'rifat al-'akhlaq,
7. Ma'rifat al-ta'rikh, and
8. Ma'rifat
al-ma'dd
Misconceptions about Nahjul Balagha
No scholar of Sunni or Shi'a profession has questioned the genuineness and authenticity of Nahj al-balagha for more than two centuries. The first person to raise doubts about its attribution to Amir al-Mu'minin was Ibn Khallikan (d. 681/1282), who, without referring to any author or source,made the following remarks about the authorship of Nahj al-balaghah: People have different opinions about the compiler of Nahj al- balaghah, a collection of the utterances of al-'Imam 'Ali ibn Abi Talib (as) There is difference as to whether it was compiled by al-Sharif al-Murtada or his brother al-Radi. It is also said that it is not at all the composition of 'Ali (as) and that the one who compiled it and attributed it to him made it himself; but Allah knows the truth. These remarks were made in Wafayat al-aya'n in connection with the account of the life and work of al-Sharif al-Murtada, al-Radi's elder brother. Ibn al-'Athir al Jazari (555-630/1160-1232) in Mukhtasar al-Wafayat, Salah al-Din al-Safadi (d. 764/1362) in al-Wafi bi al-wafayat, al-'Allamah al-Yafi'i(d. 768/1366) in Mir'at al Jinan, and Ibn al-'Imad in Shadharat al-dhahab were content just to repeat Ibn Khallikan's conjecture without bothering to substantiate it. Al-'Allamah al-Dhahabi (d. 748/1347) in Mizan ul-'i'tidal was the first person to pick up the audacity to raise the unfounded doubt to a degree of certainty a century after Ibn Khallikan. He wrote in his account of al-Murtada: Al Sharif al-Murtada, who is accused of fabricating Nahj al- balaghah, was a scholar of considerable knowledge. Whosoever sees his book Nahj al-balaghah would come to believe that it was falsely attributed to Amir al-Mu'minin (as), because it contains open abuse rather than downgrading of the two caliphs Abu Bakr and 'Umar. Contradictions and mean matters have also crept into it, which do not conform with the spirit of the Companions of the Quraysh and our knowledge of the later Companions. One is convinced that the major part of this book is forged and unauthentic. Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani (d. 748/1347) repeated al-Dhahabi's objections without bothering to probe deeper into the matter. The most interesting and at the same time the weakest part of the objections concerns ascription of the authorship of Nahj al-balaghah to al-Murtada. The objectors belonged to the Umayyad West and had deep prejudices against Shiii scholars, and perhaps under the impact of Umayyad propaganda their prejudice was so deep-rooted that even their scholarship could not rise above it. Among the four contemporaries of al-Radi and al-Murtada, three, that is, al-Tha'alibi, al-Najashi (d. 450/1058), and al-Khatib al-Baghdadi (d. 463/1071) have given accounts of both the brothers. Al Shaykh al-Tusi did not give any account of al-Radi in al-Fihrist or al-Rijal, but he did not count Nahj al-balagha among the works of al-Murtada, which dispel any conjecture attributing its authorship to him, because al-Tusi was very close to him as his student. Al-Tha'alibi and al-Khatib al-Baghdadi did not mention Nahj al-balaghah either in the account of al-Murtada or that of al-Radi.Al-Najashi in unambiguous terms attributed Nahj al-balagha to al-Radi. Al-Tusi's exclusion of Nahj al-balaghah from the works of al-Murtada,and al-Najashi's mention of it among the works of al-Radi are sufficient to prove that it was without any doubt a work of al-Radi. The objectors, who could not even determine authorship of the book exactly, depended on nothing but their whim to raise doubts about its authenticity. A more convincing proof of al-Radi's authorship of Nahj al-balaghah can be found in his own other works in which he has mentioned it. Those books are the following: 1. Khasa'is al- 'A'immah: A manuscript of this work of al-Radi is in Rida Library Rampur (India) which reveals that Fadl Allah ibn 'Ali al- Husayn al-Rawandi (d. 555/1160) accepted Khasa'is as al-Radi's work. In this book, as quoted above, al-Radi has mentioned his intention of compiling Nahj al-balaghah. 2. Haqa'iq al-tanzil: Only the fifth part of this book is accessible to us. Its authorship is unanimously attributed to al-Radi. On page 167 of this book al-Radi makes this remark: Anybody who needs a proof of our claim should refer to our book Nahj al-balaghah and think upon its contents. We have compiled all forms and genres of the utteranees of Amir al-Mu'minin (as) in this book, which comprises sermons, letters, aphorisms, and admonitions, and is divided into three independent parts, each containing a specific genre. 3. Majazat al-'athar al-Nabawiyyah: Al-Najashi and others have included this book among al-Radi's works. At two places in this book al-Radi has referred to Nah; al-balagha as a work of his own compilation. It is important to note that even Ibn Khallikan, al-Dhahabi and Ibn Hajar did not question the authenticity of the attribution of Nahj al-balaghah in its entirety to'Ali (as). They were mainly skeptical of those parts which were critical of the Caliphs Abu Bakr and 'Umar. But if we find such utterances and writings of Amir al-Mu'minin (as) in both Shi'i and non-Shi'i sources earlier than Nahjal-balaghah,baseless-ness of al-Dhahabi's and Ibn Hajar's objections can be conclusively proved. Let us again refer to Istinad-e Nahj al-balagha by 'Arshi, a contemporary Sunni scholar of India. With respect to the harshest of the sermons concerning the issue of the caliphate, known as al-Khutbat aldhiqshiqiyyah, 'Arshi refers to the following early sources in which the sermon had occurred: 1. Abu Ja'far Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Khalid al-Barqi (d.274/887) has quoted it in full in al-Mahasin wa al-'adab. 2. Ibrahim ibn Muhammad al-Thaqafi al-Kufi (d. 283/896) quoted it in al-Gharat. In his notes on al-Gharat, Sayyid Jalal al-Din Muhaddith,quoting Imtiyaz 'Ali Khan 'Arshi, says that this khutbah is not found in it; even Ibn Abi al-Hadid and al-'Allamah Muhammad Baqir al-Majlisi (1037-1110 or 1111/1627-1698 or 99) did not refer to al-Gharat as an early source of this sermon. 3. Abu 'Ali Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab al Jubba'i al-Basri al-Mu'tazili(d. 303/915 -16) narrated it. 4. Abu Ja'far Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-Rahman ibn Qubbah al-Razi (a teacherof al- Mufid and a pupil of Abu al-Qasim al-Balkhi, a Mu'tazili in his youth) quoted it in al-Insaf. 5. Abu al Qasim 'Abd Allah ibn Ahmad ibn Mahmud al-Ka'bi al-Balkhi al-Mu'tazili (d. 319/931) in al-'Insaf. 6. Abu Ja'far Muhammad ibn 'Ali ibn al-Husayn ibn Musa ibn Babawayh al-Qummi, known as alShaykh al-Saduq (d. 318/930), has quoted it in two of his books: Ilal al Sharayi' and Ma'ani al-'akhbar. 7. Abu 'Abd Allah Muhammad ibn al-Nu'man, known as al-Shaykh al-Mufid(d. 413/ 1022) inKitdb al-'irshad. 8. Shaykh al-Ta'ifah Abu Ja'far Muhammad ibn al-Hasan al-Tusi (d. 460/1068) in al-'Amali. 'Arshi adds that al Shaykh al Saduq has narrated this Khutbah on the authority of two different chains of narrators: Narrated to us Muhammad ibn 'Ali Majalawayh from his uncle Muhammad Ibn al-Qasim, he from Ahmad ibn 'Abd Allah al-Barqi he from his father, he from Ibn Abi 'Umayr, he from Aban ibn 'Uthman he from 'Aban ibn Taghlib, he from 'Ikrimah, he from 'Abd Allah ibn al-'Abbas. ('Ilal al-sharayi' and Ma'anial-' akhbar) Narrated to us Muhammad ibn Ibrahim ibn Ishaq al-Taliqani, from 'Abd al-'Aziz ibn Yahya al Jalludi, from Abu 'Abd Allah Ahmad ibn 'Ammar ibn Khalid, from Yahya ibn 'Abd al-Hamid al- Hammani, from 'Isa ibn Rashid, from 'Ali ibn Khuzaymah, from 'Ikrimah, from Ibn al-'Abbas. (Ma'ani al 'akhbar) Al-Sayyid al-Radi has not quoted the entire chain of narrators, and was content to remark that the sermon was popularly known as 'al-Shiqshiqiyyah ', while his teacher al-Mufid narrates both the chain of narrators and the story behind its narration. This is indicative of the fact that this sermon was so famous in those days that al-Radi did not find it necessary to prove its veracity by quoting the chain of its narrators. Surprisingly, the same famous sermon was used by his and 'Ali's opponents to question his veracity and to malign him by accusing him and/or his brother of forging it. The kind of criticism Ibn Khallikan and his followers dabbled in not only discredits them as researchers but also makes their other works suspicious in the eyes of impartial and objective students of history. Those who could not find any of the above-mentioned books to cross-check the veracity of Nahj al-balaghah had failed miserably even in determining correctly its authorship. Al-Shaykh al-Mufid has collected a number of 'Ali's speeches in al-'Irshad concerning the issue of the succession to the Prophet (saw) and 'Ali's criticism of the ways and means adopted by his opponents to deprive him of the caliphate. The famous Khutbah known as al-Shiq-shiqiyyah begins with the following preface: (A group of traditionists report by a variety of chains of authority (turuq) on the authority of Ibn al-'Abbas, who said:) I [i.e. Ibn al-'Abbas, was with the Commander of the Faithful at al-Rahabah I mentioned the [matter of] Caliphate and those who had preeeded him. He breathed heavily and said: "By God, Ibn Abi Quhatah took on...." This khutbah ends with the following words: Then you would have found that your world is more insignificant in my eyes than a goat's snot. At this point 'Ali's speech was interrupted by a man from Kufah. Ibn al-'Abbas, after narrating the text of the speech, adds: I have never regretted anything nor felt such distress like the distress l felt at losing the rest of the speeeh of the Commander of the Faithful, peace be on him. When he finished reading the letter, I said: "Commander of the Faithful would you continue your speech from the point which you reached?" He answered: "In no way, in no way. It was like foam on the camel's mouth (shiqshiqah) as it opens its mouth to bellow and then falls silent." Apart from al-'Irshad this khutbah, as claimed by 'Arshi, is found in other sources also. In no way can it be dubbed as al-Radi's or al-Murtada's fabrication. Sayyid Hibat al-Din al-Shahristani, in Mahuwa Nahj al-balaghah, has quoted different versions of al-Khutbat al-Shiqshiqiyyah from: Nathral-durar wa nuzhat al-'adab by the vizier Abu Sa'id al-'Abi; al-'Irshad by al- Shaykh ai-Mufid; al-Mahasin wa al-'adab by al-Barqi; al-Saduq in Ila'l al-sharayi';and a book of al-Jalludi. All the versions have minor differences, which indicate that the source from which al-Radi quoted this sermon was other than these four. After enumerating the earlier works containing this khutbah,Hibat al-Din al- Shahristani points out that Ibn 'Abd Rabbih, one of tbe compilers of al-Khutbat al-Shiqshiqiyyah, was a follower of the Banu Umayyah and a staunch admirer of the third caliph 'Uthman ibn writes: 'Affan. Much earlier than Ibn Khallikan made his remark questioning the authenticity of the attribution of Nahj al- balaghah, certain doubts had come to circulate as indicated by Ibn Abi al-Hadid al-Mu'tazili (d. 555/1257), who referred to a discussion concerning the attribution of al-Khutbat al- Shiqshiqiyyah with his teacher Abu al-Khayr Musaddiq ibn Shabib [sic. Shayb] al-Wasiti (d. 605/1208), who said: I read this khutbah in the presenee of Abu Muhammad 'Abd Allah ibn Ahmad, known as Ibn al-Khashshab (493 -567/1099-1172)... and asked him if he considered this khutbah to be a forged one and not of 'Ali (as). Ibn al-Khashshab said: By God, I am convinced that it is from 'Ali and I am as sure of it as I am convineed of your truthfulness. Al-Wasiti said to Ibn al-Khashshab: "A group is of the view that this khutbah was fabricated by al-Radi, may God be pleased with him." Ibn al-Khashshab said: Is it not beyond the eloquence of al-Radi or any other? How could he speak from such a high level of spirituality in such a (forceful) style? We are well acquainted with al-Radi's writings, his style and his technique. I have assessed both his poetry and prose, these words as compared to those of al- Radi are so different that there is no question of confusing them with his writings." He further said: By God, I have read this sermon in books written two hundred years before the birth of al-Radi. Yes, of course, I have seen it written in many books. I can identify this khutbah very well and know that which of the 'ulama' and men of letters quoted it (in his work) mueh before al-Radi's father was born." (Sharh Nahj al-balaghah, vol. I) On another occasion, in his Sharh Nahj al-balaghah, Ibn Abi al-Hadid A group of blind followers of their own whims and wishes is of the opinion that the best part of Nahj al-balagha is fabricated and forged by a group of Shi'i writers and is something new. Most of them consider a part of it to be the product of al-Radi's pen or of others. But this group consists of prejudiced people, whose heart's vision is blocked by partiality and who have deviated from the right and straight path of truth; they have strayed from truth due to perversion, lack of knowledge, and unfamiliarity with literature and poetry. (vol. 1, p. 543) At another place he writes about the words of Amir al-Mu'minin (as): His eloquence is such that he is the leader of the eloquent and the guide and master of orators. It is said about his ulterances that his words are below the Word of the Creator only, but over and above the words of all creatures; and from him the world has learnt the art of speech and rhetoric. There were people in the age of al-Radi himself whose hearts and eyes were sealed in such a manner that they attributed some of 'Ali's utterances to Mu'fiwiyah. Al-Radi's commentary on the following khutbah,is important: His comment, are as follows: People with no ability to understand literature aseribe it to Mu'awiyah whereas these are undoubtedly the words of Amir al- Mu'minin. How can dirt compare with pure gold?... 'Amr ibn Bahr al Jahiz, a critic gifted with insight and a distinct sensibility, has probed the matter minutely. He has included this khutbah in al-Bayan wa al-tabyin, and has mentioned those who attributed it to Mu'awiyah. Subsequently he says: "This speech is very much like the speeches of 'Ali (as) and is in conformity with the great man's classification of people, and it also corresponds with his manner of depicting the people's modes of behaving in anger, under oppression and waywardness, and in the state of dissimulation and fear. Similarly, al-Radi refers to his sources on a number of occasions,and also gives an account of the circumstances that were responsible for the mood and theme of a certain sermon. He has referred to: al Jahiz; al-Waqidi; Abu Ja'far al-'Iskafi; Hisham ibn al-Kalbi; Sa'id ibn Yahya ai-'Umawi, the author of al-Maghazi; Abu 'Ubayd al- Qasim ibn Salam; al-Tabari; Tha'lab; Ibn al-'A'rabi; al-Mubarrad, and many others. How could an author who allegedly forged the utterances and writings of Amir al- Mu'minin (as) be so honest in acknowledging his indebtedness to his predecessors? Those who raised doubts about the contents of Nahj al-balagha were unaware of the high status and prestige of its compiler, both in the society and in the academic circles. A man of his eminence could not even think of fabricating sermons and letters in the name of al-'Imam 'Ali (as). Had any such attempt been made by anybody, Shi'i scholars themselves would have been the first to reject it, as an anthology of poetry attributed to al-'Imam 'Ali (as) (Diwan-e 'Ali) was never accepted by the majority of Shi'i scholars as authentic. Some other such works, for example, the commentary on the Quran attributed to al- Imam al-Hasan al-'Askari (as) or Fiqh al-Rida attributed to al Imam al-Rida (as),are at issue among Shi'i scholars. But no one among al-Radi's contemporaries or from the successive generations of Sunni or Shi'i 'ulama' ever questioned Nahj al-balaghah's authenticity for more than two centuries. Regarding the contents of Nahj al-balaghah the Muslim scholars of all shades of opinion never doubted al-Radi's veracity. They were aware of the presence of earlier sources of al-'Imam 'Ali's utterances. There is abundant reliable evidence in support of the existence of such collections in the first and second centuries of Hijrah, from which 'Abd al-Hamid ibn Yahyfi, Ibn al- Muqaffa', and Zayd ibn 'Ali ibn al-Husayn ibn 'Ali ibn Abi Talib had quoted al-'Imam 'Ali's sermons and letters. In the third and fourth centuries, too, several collections of 'Ali's khutab and rasa'il were compiled, some of which have been already referred to above. Ibn Abi al-Hadid (d. 655 or 656/1257 or 58); Taqi al-Din Ahmad, known as Ibn Taymiyyah (661-728/1263-1328); and his pupil Salah al-Din al-Safadi (d.764/1362 -63) accepted Nahj al-balaghah as a genuine collection of al Imam 'Ali's words. The former not only wrote one of the most famous commentaries on it, but also repudiated all doubts about its authenticity. Ibn Taymiyyah and al-Safadi were among staunch opponents and critics of the Shi'ah, but both of them verified the authenticity of Nahj al-balagha and the veracity of al-Sharif al-Radi. Al-Safadi, in the account of al-Radi, writes: People are of the view that Nahj al-balaghah is his own writing. But I heard my teacher, al-'Imam al-'Allamah Taqi al-Din Ahmad ibn Taymiyyah say: "Nahj al-balaghah is not al-Sayyid al-Radi's product. What in this book is the utterance of 'Ali ibn Abi Talib (as) is known, and whatever is from al-Radi that is also known. (al-Wafi bi al-wafayat, vol. 2, p. 375) Instead of going into further details of the controversy about the authenticity of Nahj al- balaghah's ascription and forwarding more evidence against those who created doubts about it, I would recommend the keen reader to consult al-Mu'jam al-mufahras li alfaz Nahj al-balaghah, edited by al-Sayyid Kazim al-Muhammadi and al-Shaykh Muhammad al-Dashti, who have done a commendable job in preparing a very comprehensive bibliography of the sources of the book along with a detailed item- by-item list of the sources of each and every sermon, letter, and saying contained in Nahj al-balaghah. Moreover, since the death of al-Radi scholars of eminence have been always interested in writing commentaries on Nahj al-balagha, which is another very strong proof of its authenticity. So many Sunni, Mu'tazili, and Shi'i scholars would not have taken pains to comment upon al Radi's own fabrications. 'Ali Naqi Munzawi, in the catalogue of the library of Mishkat, donated to Tehran University, has enumerated 33 narrators of al-'Imam 'Ali's utterances before al-Radi and fourteen after him till the tenth Hijrah century. Danish Pizhoh, in his preface to Farman-e Malik Ashtar, edited by Husayn 'Alawi Awi, has given a list of its early commentators. Sayyid 'Abd al-Zahra' al-Khatib, in Masadir Nahj al balagha wa asaniduh, has counted thirty-three books written concerning the sources of Nahj al- balaghah. Hundreds of manuscripts of Nahj al-balaghah in various libraries of the world and even a greater number of the manuscripts of other earlier works containing al-'Imam 'Ali's utterances invite all seekers of truth to trace the sources and ascertain the authenticity of Nahj al-balaghah. There are also numerous documents available which contain certificates and testimonials issued by eminent scholars to their pupils authorizing them to narrate the contents of Nahj al-balaghah along with the permission to narrate ahadith of the Prophet (saw) and the Imams (as). This is enough to show that Nahj al-balaghah has been considered to be of equal value in reliability with the most authentic compendiums of hadith. The narration of Nahj al-balagha's traditions had started during the lifetime of al-Radi. Qutb al-Din al-Rawandi (d. 573/1177) in the preface of his commentary on Nahj al- balaghoh, refers to a daughter of al-Sharif al Murtada, who had studied the book under al-Radi himself and was authorized to narrate its traditions to others, and she used to narrate Nahj al-balaghah on her uncle's authority. Shaykh 'Abd al-Rahim al-Baghdadi has narrated from this learned lady of the family of the Imams (as).
A Perspective of Imamat in Nahjul Balagha
'One who dies without recognizing the Imam of his time, dies the death of
ignorance.'
This means that even if a person accepts and conforms to all the Islamic
beliefs and puts in practice all the edicts, but dies without recognizing the
Imam of his time, his death will be on ignorance and apostasy. Such a person is
condemned to eternal Hellfire regardless of his deeds in this world. This is
because good deeds will only benefit a person provided his beliefs are correct,
as espoused by the Quran and traditions. Hence, any person, who wants to secure
himself from the raging fire of hell, should necessarily possess the
recognition of the Imam of his time and not simply rely on his worship and
virtuous deeds.
Two kinds of Imams
The Holy Quran has mentioned two types of leaders (Imams). The first type is
the one who leads the people towards Hell. Allah declares in Surah Qasas, verse
41,
'And We made them Imams who call to the Fire, and on the Day of Resurrection
they shall not be assisted.'
It means that the end of the one who accepts such an Imam will be in Hell.
The second group of Imams guides the people by Allah's command. Surah Sajdah,
verse 24 points out
'And We made of them Imams to guide by Our command when they were patient, and
they were certain of Our communications.'
'Say: Is there any of your associates who guides to the truth? Say: Allah
guides to the truth. Is He then Who guides to the truth more worthy to be followed,
or he who himself does not go aright unless he is guided? What then is the
matter with you; how do you judge?'
(Surah Yunus, Verse 35)
Ameerul Momineen Ali (a.s.) has described the characteristics of both kinds of
Imams in his orations. 'The reality of people is not understood by their names
but by the pattern of their behavior and mannerisms. Just as clothes hide the
defects of the body, external manners cloak the defects of the soul. A
connection of the soul is a necessity between the Imam and the follower. If a
person (i.e. Imam) is not pious in his own heart, he will not be able to guide
his followers towards piety and servitude. Hence if we desire Heaven and want
to safeguard our eternal life from the chastisement of the Hellfire, then we have
to search for an Imam whose inner and outer selves both are complete
manifestations of divine command. Such an Imam must necessarily be adorned with
piety completely, i.e. must be an infallible.
We will discuss the characteristics of the Imam of Hellfire and the Imam who
guides to the truth, in the light of the sermons of Hazrat Ali (a.s.).
The Imam of the Hellfire
'…certainly, the worst man before Allah is the oppressive Imam who has gone
astray and through whom others go astray. He destroys the accepted Sunnah and
revives abandoned innovations. I heard the Messenger of Allah (s.a.w.a.)
predict - On the Day of Judgment the oppressive Imam will be brought without
anyone to support him or anyone to advance excuses on his behalf, and then he
will be thrown into Hell, where he will rotate as the hand-mill rotates. Then
eventually he will be confined to its hollow.'
(Nahjul Balagha, Sermon 164, vol. 1, pg. 608-609, Ansariyan Publications)
An oppressor is not only the one who usurps the rights of others and persecutes
others. The Quran declares,
'…and whoever exceeds the limits of Allah these it is that are the unjust.'
(Surah Baqarah, Verse 229)
These include those disobedient of Allah's commands, who have violated His
edicts and exceeded His limits. The Quran further proclaims,
'and whoever did not judge by what Allah revealed, those are they that are the
unjust.'
(Surah Maidah, Verse 45)
If somebody makes additions to the religion or forbids an obligation, he has
violated the divine command which tantamount to injustice.
Therefore, any person who has not been appointed an Imam by Allah and he claims
this position for himself, he has transgressed the limits of Allah and has
disregarded Allah's orders. He is a tyrannical and an oppressive leader, whose
end has been described above in Hazrat Ali's (a.s.) sermon.
Indeed the Holy Quran condemns even those people as oppressors who befriend
such persons -
'…and whoever makes friends with them, these are the unjust.'
(Surah Mumtahenah, Verse 9)
Imam of light and guidance
Ameerul Momineen Ali (a.s.) outlines the characteristics of the just and
rightly guided Imam,
'You should know that among the creatures of Allah, the most distinguished
person before Allah is the just Imam who has been guided (by Allah) and guides
others. So, he stands by the recognized ways of the Prophet's (s.a.w.a.)
behavior (Sunnah) and destroys the innovations. The (Prophet's (s.a.w.a.)) ways
are clear and they have signs, while innovations are also clear and they too
have signs.'
(Nahjul Balagha, Sermon 164, vol. 1, pg. 608, Ansariyan Publications)
In another sermon, Hazrat Ali (a.s.) declares,
'Certainly the Imams are the vicegerents of Allah over His creatures and they
introduce Allah to His creatures. None will enter Paradise except he who
recognizes them (Imams) and knows Allah, and no one will enter Hell except he
who rejects them and denies Him.
(Nahjul Balagha, Sermon 152, vol. 1, pg. 554, Ansariyan Publications)
He elaborates on this further,
'O my Allah! You know that it was neither our (Ahle Bait) objective to seek
power, nor to acquire anything from the treasures of the world. Rather we
wanted to restore the signs of Your religion and to spread prosperity into Your
cities so that the oppressed among Your creatures may be safe and Your forsaken
commands could be established. O my Allah! I am the first who was inclined
(towards Thee) and who heard and responded (to the call of Islam). No one
preceded me in prayer except the Prophet (s.a.w.a.).'
'You certainly know that he who is in charge of honor, life, booty,
(enforcement of) legal commands and the leadership of the Muslims should not be
a miser as his greed would aim at their wealth. Similarly he should not be
ignorant as he would then mislead them with his ignorance, nor should he be
rude as he would estrange them with his rudeness. He should not be unjust in
distributing wealth by preferring one group to another, nor should he accept
bribes while taking decisions, as he would forfeit the rights of some and
decree without decisiveness, nor should he ignore the Sunnah as he would ruin
the people.
(Nahjul Balagha, Sermon 131, vol. 1, pg. 496, Ansariyan Publications)
By referring to these brilliant sermons, it becomes abundantly clear that the
leader and Imam who possesses the following characteristics can alone guide the
people towards the truth.
1. He is guided.
2. He guides others towards the true path.
3. He enlivens the Sunnah.
4. He destroys innovations.
5. His recognition is the cause of deliverance for the people.
6. His rejection is the cause of eternal chastisement.
7. He does not desire worldly power and authority.
8. He does not crave for the treasures of the world.
9. He makes manifest the signs of religion.
10. He establishes peace and tranquility in Allah's cities.
11. He provides shelter to His oppressed servants.
12. He revives the forgotten commands.
13. He is not a miser.
14. He is not ignorant.
15. His traits and mannerisms are not evil and wicked.
16. He is not a coward.
17. He is not a corrupt.
18. He does not destroy the Sunnah.
Imam Ali (a.s.) highlights the above points in another sermon,
'Certainly, there is no obligation on the Imam except what has been devolved on
him from Allah, namely to convey warnings, to exhort and advice, to revive the
Sunnah, enforce penalties on those liable and issue shares to the deserving.'
(Nahjul Balagha, Sermon 105, vol. 1, pg. 400, Ansariyan Publications)
The Ahle Bait (a.s.)
If we search for the characteristics of the rightly guided Imam, we find that
these traits are present only in the pure and infallible members of the Ahle
Bait (a.s.). Hazrat Ali (a.s.) exhorts,
'Look at the people of the Prophet's (s.a.w.a.) family - Ahle Bait (a.s.).
Adhere to their direction. Follow their footsteps because they will never
misguide you, and never throw you into destruction. If they sit down, you too
must sit down, and if they rise, you also rise. Do not go ahead of them, as you
will go astray and do not lag behind them, as you will be ruined.
(Nahjul Balagha, Sermon 97, vol. 1, pg. 378, Ansariyan Publications)
'Where are those people who have lied and have tormented us and have
deceitfully claimed that they are 'the ones firmly rooted in knowledge' and not
us? (They lie against us and covet over position) because Allah, the
All-Merciful has exalted our status and has made them inferior to us. He has
conferred upon us an eminence from which He prevented them from surpassing us.
He allowed us entry to the transcendental sphere of divine revelation, which He
denied them. Remember that guidance could be acquired and ignorance could be
dispelled through us only. Undoubtedly the Imams shall be from the Quraish,
from the Bani Hashim. This divine appointment has been made for this august
progeny, and none else deserves this sublime and sacred rank.'
(Nahjul Balagha, Sermon 144, vol. 1, pg. 528, Ansariyan Publications)
These assertive and decisive statements make it abundantly clear that the
rightful possessors of Imamat and Caliphate are the Ahle Bait (a.s.). No one
else is deserving of this honor and station. Only the Ahle Bait (a.s.) can
direct the people to the path of guidance and lead them to paradise. If
somebody considers a person other than them as his leader, guide and Imam, he
has deviated and is far from guidance.
When Imam Ali (a.s.) appointed Janab Mohammad Ibne Abi Bakr as governor of
Egypt, he (a.s.) wrote a letter to him in which he said:
'The leader towards guidance, and the leader towards destruction, the friend
and the enemy of the Messenger of Allah (s.a.w.a.), can never be alike.'
(Nahjul Balagha, Letter No. 27, vol. 2, pg. 314, Ansariyan Publications)
Imam Ali (a.s.) has tried to awaken the consciousness of man with this powerful
statement. The statement appeals to the people to open their eyes and refer to
their intellects and then decide with deep reflection - Are the leaders of
guidance and the path bearers to paradise equal to the guides towards the hell
fire and darkness? Never! Awaken and decide for yourselves.
Chain of guidance
It is crystal clear that Imamat is the exclusive right of the Ahle Bait (a.s.)
and anyone who claims this right for himself/themselves is a liar and an
oppressor. There is a well-known tradition from the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a.)
widely narrated by all scholars and traditionalists in their books. The Holy
Prophet (s.a.w.a.) prophesied,
'This nation will have twelve leaders and guides and all of them will be from
the Quraish. The one who leaves them will not harm them.' (i.e. the one who has
distanced himself will be among the losers, because his death will be that of
ignorance).
(Musnad-e-Ahmad b. Hanbal, vol.5, pg. 312)
The tradition of the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a.) clearly highlights that there will
only be twelve Imams till the Day of Judgment and all these leaders will be
from the tribe of Quraish. Within the Quraish, the Imams will be from Bani
Hashim. From the traditions mentioned above we conclude that after the demise
of the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a.) till the Day of Resurrection, this nation will
have twelve Imams and all of them will be from Bani Hashim.
Regarding the tradition from the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a.) -
'I leave among you two weighty things (Saqalain), the Book of Allah and my
progeny',
Imam Ali (a.s.) was asked - Who is the progeny? He (a.s.) replied:
I, Hasan (a.s.), Husain (a.s.) and the nine Imams (a.s.) from the progeny of
Husain (a.s.), of whom the ninth one will be the Mahdi (a.t.f.s.) and the Qaem
(a.t.f.s.). Neither will they separate from the Book of Allah nor will the Book
of Allah separate from them, till they meet the Messenger of Allah (s.a.w.a.)
at the Pool of Kausar.'
(Kamaluddin, vol.1, pg. 240-241)
Aamir bin Kasir asked Imam Ali (a.s.): O Ameerul Momineen (a.s.)! You have made
us aware of the guides of disbelief and the caliphs of evil, now introduce to
us the guides of truth and the real guides after you.' Imam Ali (a.s.) informed
him,
'Yes, surely it is the promise of the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a.) to me that this
religion will have twelve Imams and leaders, nine of whom will be from the
progeny of Husain (a.s.). The Messenger of Allah (s.a.w.a.) has narrated, 'When
I went to the heavens for Meraj, I saw written on the pillar of the Arsh
'There is no god except Allah, Mohammad (s.a.w.a.) is His Messenger, and I have
aided him through Ali (a.s.) and I have helped him through Ali (a.s.)'
And I saw twelve Lights. I asked:
O My Lord! Whose lights are these?
The reply was -
These lights are of Imams from your progeny.
Then I (Ali (a.s.)) asked:
O Messenger of Allah, will you not tell me their names?'
The Holy Prophet replied,
'Yes, certainly. You are Imam and Caliph after me, you will repay my debts and
fulfill my promises. After you will be your two sons, Hasan (a.s.) and Husain
(a.s.), and after Husain (a.s.) will be his son Ali - Zainul Abedeen (a.s.),
after Ali (a.s.) will be his son Mohammad (a.s.) whose title is Baqir. After
Mohammad (a.s.) will follow his son Jafar (a.s.) whose title is Sadiq. After
Jafar (a.s.), will be his son Moosa (a.s.) whose title is Kazim. After Moosa
(a.s.), will be his son Ali (a.s.) whose title is Reza. After Ali, his son
Mohammad (a.s.) will succeed him and his title is Zaki. After Mohammad (a.s.)
will follow his son Ali (a.s.) whose title is Naqi. After Ali (a.s.) will come
his son Hasan (a.s.) whose title is Ameen and Askari. After him will be the son
of Hasan (a.s.), Qaem (a.t.f.s.), whose name will be my name and who will bear
maximum similarity with me. He will fill the earth with justice and equity as
it would have been filled with oppression and injustice.'
(Vol. 1, pg. 138, Imam Ali (a.s.) narrated about the condition of Imam Mahdi
(a.s.))
There isn't just one tradition like this. We find several traditions on these
lines and the number goes up to 20. For instance, Imam Ali (a.s.) recounts from
the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a.) who has categorically stated that from the time of
his (s.a.w.a.) death till the Day of Qiyamat there will only be twelve Imams,
and then each has been mentioned by his name.
The entire arrangement was made so that people would know that Allah and His
Prophet (s.a.w.a.) had already selected the Imams. It was not that anyone could
be an Imam according to the wishes of the Islamic nation. It was not that an
Imam who was supposed to follow his father in the chain of Imamat, died in his
father's lifetime, leaving the chain of Imamat suspended until the people
appointed the deceased's son as the Imam in his place.
All the above traditions, were narrated when Janabe Ismail b. Jafar Sadiq was
not even born. The list of Imams (a.s.) narrated by the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a.)
and Imam Ali (a.s.) does not show Janabe Ismail's name. Therefore, if he was
never destined to be an Imam then where does the question of usurping his
Imamat arise?
Another thing that is evident is that the twelve Imams (a.s.) enumerated in the
prophetic tradition mentions the first Imam as Imam Ali (a.s.) and the twelfth
and last Imam as Hazrat Wali-e-Asr (a.t.f.s.), who is the Imam of our time and
is alive on this earth today and is amongst us but we are deprived of his
meeting due to our sins and disobedience.
Asbagh bin Nubata (r.a.) a very reliable companion of Hazrat Ali (a.s.)
narrates, 'I presented myself before Hazrat Ali (a.s.). I saw that he was
engrossed in some thought and marking with his blessed finger on the earth. I
queried, 'O Ameerul Momineen (a.s.)! What is the matter, I find you today in
some perplexity, making signs on the earth, do you love this earth? He (a.s.)
replied:
I swear by Allah that it is not so. I have never befriended this world, rather
I was reflecting about that son, the eleventh one from my progeny. He is the
Mahdi (a.t.f.s.), who will fill the earth with justice and equity as it was
filled with injustice and tyranny. There is an occultation for him in which
some people will be deviated while others will be guided.
(Kamaluddin, vol.1, pg. 288-297, A'laamul Wara, pg. 400)
How clearly Hazrat Ali (a.s.) has described and illuminated the chain of
guidance and Imamat. Who could be more unfortunate and wretched that despite
such a clear and illumined chain of guidance and Imamat, rejects it for those
deviated guides who have usurped Hazrat Ali's (a.s.) right? Those who have
harassed and persecuted Janabe Zahra (s.a.), burned down her door and waged war
against her husband - the rightful Imam and celebrated on his martyrdom and
were the main protagonists of the incident of Karbala. Their sons killed Imam
Husain (a.s.) in Karbala, they made captives the Ahle Bait (a.s.) and martyred
them one after the other. Their lives were devoid of Islamic teachings, they
opposed the Quranic commands secretly and publicly, they were steeped in sins
and prohibited acts and abandoned the religious obligations completely. They
were prisoners of their carnal desires and neglected the hereafter and in this
manner deprived themselves of guidance. Then how was it possible for them to
guide others?
Guidance has only one path and that path is the way of Hazrat Ali Ibne Abi
Talib (a.s.), finally terminating in Imam Mahdi (a.t.f.s.) who is the Imam
today. There is no other path leading to true guidance and there is no other
guarantee for success and happiness in the world and the hereafter.
We end this discussion with the declaration of Hazrat Ali (a.s.) inviting
everyone to leave aside prejudices and rise above personal interests, to purify
the intellect and consciousness, to decide about one's own end, lest the coming
of the Angel of Death finds us perplexed and uncertain. Today there is time and
tomorrow could be too late. Our decision will take us either to Paradise or to
Hell. Let us not spoil our hereafter for this fleeting world.
'Observe this world, which you desire, towards which you move with desire and
proximity, which sometimes angers you and at other times makes you happy. It is
neither your actual abode nor the station for which you were created, nor is it
the place towards which you are invited.'
'Take lesson, for it is not going to remain for you, nor are you in it forever.
If it has beguiled you with its charm then it has also made you fearful with
its wickedness. Do not be influenced by its scare and do not seek it greedily
out of its fear.'
'Advance towards that abode towards which you have been invited and turn your
hearts away from this world. None of you should lament like maids on
deprivation of a thing of this world. Be patient on the obedience of Allah and
wish for the completion of the bounties by safeguarding that which has been
commanded by our Book to be safeguarded.'
'Pay heed, if you have safeguarded your religious beliefs then loss of anything
of this world will not harm you. And if you have wasted and destroyed your
religion then none of the worldly things, which you have safeguarded, can bring
you any benefit.'
(Nahjul Balagah, Sermon 173, vol. 1, pg. 644, Ansariyan Publications)
Freedom, Human Destiny,
and the World in the Nahj al-balaghah:
"….(God) has given inborn disposition to human minds to shape themselves either towards good or towards evil". (11) (Khutbah: 75)
"They were given complete liberty in this world, of thought and deed, to
think as they like and to do as they desire, so that they may develop their
minds, and with the help of such developed minds, free will, and the span of
life allotted to them, find the purpose for which they were created...."
(12) (Khutbah: 86).
In Khutbah 86, Imam Ali (a.s) further says that human beings are given sound
bodies and limbs with perfect senses to acquire the knowledge of the external
world and the light of reason and wisdom, so that they are able to exercise
their freedom of thought and action. (13) This point forms a recurring theme of
the Nahj al-Balaghah, for a sound body, sound senses, and reason are necessary
conditions for exercising freedom. Those who are deficient in these respects
are not held responsible for their acts, such as insane persons and infants. Solely
those endowed with these things are responsible for their acts:
"Lives of men who were enjoying themselves to their hearts' content and
had perfect freedom of action have such useful lessons in them to teach
...." (Khutbah: 86) (14)
From the above-quoted passages, certain points can be inferred: man is given
complete freedom with the ability to exercise it; freedom has a purpose: to
realize and obey Allah and act in a just manner. Justice can be defined as
maintaining an equilibrium among various obligations and rights. One has to be
just to oneself. There are many verses in the Qur'an and innumerable passages
in the Nahj al-balaghah restraining men from indulging in excesses even in
desirable deeds, such as generosity, excess of which is israf and is
prohibited. Doing justice to others, which ensures social and political
morality, and just behaviour in relation to God, requires abstaining from
overindulgence in ritual worship. By maintaining justice in all the three
aspects--that is in relation to oneself, others and God--man is free to
determine his destiny. In contemporary Western philosophy existentialism is
credited with introducing the notion of man's freedom in shaping and moulding
his own destiny, but a glance at the Nahj al-Balaghah is sufficient to arrive
at the conclusion that it was Imam Ali (a.s) who advanced this idea for the
first time:
If by destiny you mean compulsion (physical or otherwise) whereby we are forced
(by nature) to do a thing, then it is not so. Had it been an obligation of that
kind, then there would have been no question of reward for doing it and
punishment for not doing it (such as breathing, sleeping and eating are
physical necessities entailing no reward or punishment), and the promised
blessings and punishments in afterlife will have no meanings. The Merciful Lord
has given His creatures complete freedom to do as they like, and they are
prohibited from certain actions and warned of the consequences of such actions.
These commands carry in them the least trouble and lead us towards the most
convenient way of life .... He sees people disobeying Him and tolerates them,
not because He can be overruled or be compelled to accept human supremacy over
Him. 1-Ie did not send His prophets to amuse Himself or provide amusement for
them. He did not reveal His orders without any reason and purpose. Neither has
He created the galaxies and the earth without any design, purpose, and
programme. A universe without plan, purpose, and programme is the idea of the
infidels and heathens; sorry will be their plight in the fires and the hell...
(Sayings: 78) (Destiny) was an order of God to do it, like the order he has
given in His Holy Book "You are destined to worship him and nobody
else". Here destined means "ordered", it does not mean physical
compulsion. (15)
From this brief saying, many points relevant to philosophical and moral issues
can be derived: determining one's destiny is an act of man's free will,
different from physical compulsion; Divine commands are rationally designed and
have a purpose; the universe itself has a design and a purpose; in this
purposive scheme of creation man is free to act or not to act in accordance
with the Divine purpose; voluntary acts of men deserve reward or punishment
according to their nature; and that freedom brings in its wake responsibility.
Kant, who could not bring himself to accept the existence of God on the
strength of ontological, causal, and teleological arguments, had to evolve a
moral proof for the existence of God, in which God, freedom of human will, and
life after death served as the essential postulates of morality. If we compare
Imam Ali's approach to the problems of freedom, morality, purposiveness of
creation, and the existence of God, we may come to a more convincing
philosophy. Imam Ali does not require any proof for the existence of God, but
believes in Him on the ground of revelation and his own inner experience. This
is the same stand which was taken in the West by Kierkegaard in the 19th
century after realizing the inadequacy of reason in proving or disproving God.
Recent theology in the West accepts the inner yearning of man to have faith in
a Supreme Being as the only criterion of belief in God. Starting from the same
position Ali (a.s) proves the purposiveness of creation, arguing that it is
created by an intelligent, knowing, and just God with a design and a purpose,
and all His commands are just and reasonable, for He does not command man to do
something that is beyond his capacity. Human freedom is an essential
constituent of this purposive world, without which man would not have been able
to pursue certain goals. It is also necessary for morality, which comprises
voluntary actions. Thus freedom is not a postulate in Imam Ali's world-outlook,
hut an organic part of a just and purposive order. His firm faith in a just God
makes him believe in the Hereafter. In this way, the Islamic world-outlook he
presents is more coherent and consistent than that of Kant or any other Western
philosopher. In this system, human reason does not give rise to antimonies,
because it is not required to trespass the region of faith or inner experience.
All the three axioms of morality which Kant derived from his moral philosophy
follow in Ali's Islamic system of thought from faith in God and freedom of human
will. In the world conceived by him all individuals are free and they form a
"kingdom of ends that is the beings sovereign in this world and only
subordinate to Divine commandments. They are not subservient to other human
beings and are masters of their own destiny. In this sense Imam Ali (a.s)
considers this world of ours better than any conceivable worlds. There is a
saying of his that refutes the commonly believed notion that the Imam (a.s)
despised the world and his approach to it was ascetic and pessimistic. He heard
someone abusing the world and said to him that it was not the world which
deceived man but it was man who was allured and enchanted by it, and
subsequently debased himself and polluted the world. He said:
Verily this world is a house of truth for those who look into it carefully, an
abode of peace and rest for those who understand its ways and moods, and it is
the best working ground for those who want to procure rewards for their life in
the Hereafter. It is a place of acquiring knowledge and wisdom for those who
want to acquire them, a place of worship for the friends of God and for angels.
It is the place where prophets receive revelations of the Lord. It is the place
for virtuous people and the Saints to do good deeds and to be assigned with
rewards for the same; only in this world they could trade with God's favours
and blessings, and only while living here they could barter their good deeds
with His blessings and rewards. Where else could all this be done? (16)
(Sayings: 130)
This passage may remind one of Leibnitz's saying: "Ours is the best of all
possible worlds", which reflects an optimistic view of the physical world.
Ali (a.s) regards it so because it is here and here alone that man's freedom is
tested as to how far he acts justly. In the light of this passage we can
justify Iqbal's view that man chose freely to leave Heaven and come to this
world.
Right to Acquire Knowledge: Nahj al-balaghah's Approach
Knowledge of the creation in general, and of this world in particular, is
emphasized by Imam Ali (a.s) in the Nahj al-balaghah as a prerequisite for
making use of freedom in the right direction and for the purpose willed by God.
Knowledge, if used properly, helps man in winning God's favour and bartering
his deeds with Divine Will, as the Qur'an declares: "And among men is he
who sells his self for seeking the pleasures of Allah...." (al-Baqarah:
207)
Those who attain such a stage are few, and as many mufassirun point out Ali
(a.s) as one of those chosen few who bartered his self with Divine Will,
according to the interpretation of this Qur'anic verse. When human will becomes
one with Divine Will, man attains the highest stage of freedom: now there is no
compulsion, and whatever a man wills or does is in conformity with what God
wills and wants man to do. Rightly guided knowledge helps in attaining this
stage. After expressing his view on human freedom, Imam Ali (a.s) proceeds to
highlight the value and importance of knowledge. We find after the saying 78
about freedom, his views about knowledge and wisdom in the saying 79, or in his
saying 130 we come across his views on the significance of acquiring knowledge
and contemplating the signs observable in the world after his description of
the world as the best place for making proper use of human freedom. Knowledge
is held by Ali (a.s) to be the light of reason, a treasure, the root of all
good, and that which emancipates man; it is a power (saying: 146), (17) and
one's supremacy is in proportion to the extent of one's knowledge and wisdom
(Sayings: 175) (18)
From his many sayings about knowledge it may be rightly inferred that knowledge
is itself freedom, for it saves man from ignorance, which is the cause of man's
slavery to false beliefs, unfounded fear of nature and his superiors. It is at
the same time a key to attain and safeguard freedom accorded to human beings.
The Qur'an is unique among the scriptures in encouraging the believers to
acquire knowledge and to verify the fundamentals of faith rationally. There are
704 verses in the Qur`an where the word 'ilm or its derivations are used. Book,
an essential aid of 'ilm occurs in the Qur'an 230 times, while the total number
of verses in which words related to kitab and kataba have occurred is 319. The
Qur'an itself is mentioned as kitab on 81 occasions in its text. It is not
possible in this brief article to quote even a few of the relevant Qur'anic
verses and the sayings of Ali (a.s). However, it would not be out of place to
point out that the right to acquire knowledge and freedom of enquiry forms an
essential part of the laws and guiding principles governing human rights in
Islam. In this matter, no distinction is made between Islamic and non-Islamic
sources and Muslim and non-Muslim teachers. Ali (a.s) says:
"Acquire knowledge and truth from whomever you can, because even an
apostate can have them, hut unless they are passed over to a faithful Muslim
and become part of wisdom and truth that he possesses, they have a confused
existence in the minds of apostates". (Sayings: 79). (19)
Another saying of Ali (a.s) is an elaboration of the Prophet's famous
tradition, according to which knowledge is the lost property of Muslims:
"A wise saying is a lost and long-sought article of the believer.
Therefore, acquire it even if it is to be found with hypocrites".
(Sayings: 80). (20)
The right to acquire knowledge has been always accorded to non-Muslims also in
Muslim States. An important point made by Ali (a.s) is as to how an infidel
uses knowledge, which remains in a confused state in his mind. The truth of
this view is evident in our age, for modern knowledge, as pointed out by modern
thinkers, is devoid of human considerations and has dehumanized its retainers
and creators. All the uses of scientific discoveries and advancements for inventing
and selling the weapons of mass destruction indicate the absence of a right
worldview. Islam, on the other hand, humanizes all knowledge in the light of
Divine guidance, which leads to a humanized world outlook. Being fully aware of
the dangers of the abuse of knowledge, Ali (a.s) claims that God will always
appoint some Imam as the guardian of Divine revelation and he, openly or hidden
from the eyes of the world, will guide men till the end of this world. (Saying
146 addressed to Kumayl) (21) Thus the right to receive unceasing Divine
guidance, along with the right to knowledge and enjoy freedom of thought and
expression forms the foundation-stone of the Islamic universal declaration of
human rights. The constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran ensures the
right to knowledge and freedom of learning through various articles. Article 2,
clause 6, declares that the Islamic Republic is based on faith in Allah, belief
in the exalted dignity of man and his freedom coupled with responsibility
before God, and that equity, justice, political, economic, social, and cultural
independence are secured by recourse to: (a) continuous ijtihad of the fuqaha'.
(b) and sciences and arts and the most advanced results of human experience,
together with the effort to advance them further. An article of the first
chapter states that the Islamic Republic has the duty of directing all its
resources to raising the level of public awareness and the spirit of inquiry,
investigation, and innovation in all areas of science. (22) These rights are
not confined to Muslims only, hut are accorded to non-Muslim citizens as well
in the light of Article 19 (Chapter III), which states that: "All people
of Iran, whatever the ethnic group and tribe they belong to, enjoy equal
rights; and colour, race, language, and the like, do not bestow any privilege.
(23) These articles are in conformity with the Islamic view of human rights.
Underprivileged Sections of the People and Their Rights:
Islam paid special attention to weaker sections of society, for stronger
sections not only get what is rightfully their due, but also grab what belongs
to weaker sections. Christ had pleaded and fought for the oppressed, but when
his followers came to power they adopted the same system which was based on
according privileges to the ruling class and the priests. On the contrary,
Islam granted special rights to the underprivileged, so that their rights are
not denied to them and any violations of them were redressed. Woman as a whole
had been suppressed by all pre-Islamic societies both in the East and the West.
The social status and legal position of slaves had been even worse. With the
establishment of Islamic rule, a new class of weaker people came into
existence, that is non-believers living under Muslim rule. Besides slaves,
there had been always in existence a class of have-nots consisting of small
peasants, landless labourers, poor artisans, orphans, widows, mentally and
physically handicapped, the sick and the old, prisoners and travellers (ibn
al-sabil). The Qur'an makes special mention of all these classes while laying
down the principles of justice and framing laws according rights to the people.
To help the deprived the Qur`an commands emphatically and repeatedly to give
zakat, and also recommends the disbursement of sadaqat among the needy.
Zakat and sadaqh are usually translated as alms and charity, but in the Qur'an
they are defined in much better terms. Zakat has two meanings: purification,
and the cause of blessing and abundance. Both the meanings are derived from the
following Qur'anic verses: al-Nur: 21, al-Kahf: 74, al-'A'la: 14 & 15, and
Fatir: 19. In interpreting the verses from the surahs al-'A'la and Fatir, some
exegetes have interpreted tazakka in the sense of zakat. sadaqah also has the same
meaning according to verses 103 and 104 of al-Tawbah.(24) Both zakat and
sadaqah are means of purifying one's riches, with the difference that zakat is
obligatory and sadaqah is recommendatory. Muslims are distinguished from
mushrikun, that is polytheists and idolaters, on the ground that the latter do
not give zakat (Ha' Mim : 6-7). From the sixth and seventh verses of 'Ha' Mim'
it is inferred that mushrikun are also obliged to give zakat according to the
Muslim law. Paying of zakat, which may be translated as poor-rate or poor-due,
is considered by the Qur'an as a more valid criterion of a Muslim's faith than
offering of prayers:
"It is not righteousness that you turn your faces towards the East and the
West, but righteousness is this that one should believe in Allah and the Last
Day and the angels and the Book and the prophets and give away wealth out of
love for Hun to near of kin and the orphans and the needy and the wayfarers and
the beggars and for (the emancipation of) the captives; and keep up prayer and
pay the zakat...." (al-Baqarah: 177).
As the special categories of people deserving to receive zakst are enumerated,
similarly dadaqah also, as specifically mentioned, is to he given to the poor
and the needy, the officials in charge of collecting the zakat, those whose
hearts are made to incline' (to Islam) (al-mu'allafal al-qulub), the (ransoming
of) captives, those in debt, and in the way of Allah and the way-farer
(al-Tawbah: 60). (25)
Thus zakat is due to seven categories: the needy, the poor, the collectors of
zakat ,the mu'allafat al-qulub, ransoming of captives and emancipating slaves,
the indebted, and the wayfarers; an eighth category is added to it, that is
public funds for the construction and administration of the mosques,
educational institutions, water works, and for meeting the expenses of jihad.
(26) Special mention is made of paying devote their entire time and energy to
worship, and self-respecting people who never go to ask for help despite
extreme poverty (al-Baqarah: 273). (27)
The needy and poor of the lineage of the Prophet (s.a.w), who are prohibited
from accepting zakat and sadaqah, are taken care of by allocating to them one
half of khums; the first half of which is reserved for God and the Prophet
(s.a.w) and the Imam (a.s) of his Family.
Abu Hanifah is of the view that the part reserved for the Prophet (s.a.w) is
invalidated after the Prophet's demise, (28) but the Imamiyyah Shi'ah reserve
it for the maraji', in the absence of the Imam (a.s). The remaining part of
khums is reserved for the orphans, the needy and the way-farers. Regarding this
also the Shi'ah differ from Ahl al-Sunnah. While the former say that these
three parts are also reserved for the Banü Hashim, and particularly the
Talibiyyun, the later hold that this three-fifth of khums money is specified
for the needy among Muslims in general. So far as the definition of dhawi
al-qurba is concerned, Shi'i and Sunni fuqaha' again differ. Shi'i fuqaha' hold
that this term includes all the relations of the Prophet (s.a.w) without any
specification, but Sunnis say that only needy in the Prophet's family come
under this category. Shi'i fuqaha' reject this interpretation for the absence
of any evidence in the Qur'anic text to support it. (29)
Despite these minor differences among various schools of fiqh, the Qur`anic
injunctions concerning zakat and khums are generally followed by all Muslims.
It is also accepted that zakat is over and above the obligatory payments to be
made towards meeting the essential needs of parents and other dependants, and
these payments (nafaqah) are not to he covered under the head of zakat, which
is only for the eight categories enumerated above. Thus Islamic law has taken
care of all the weaker sections of society, and has entitled them to claim their
rights from the rulers and upper classes. In a way Islam does not recognize any
upper classes and is opposed to the amassing of huge property and hoarding of
riches unproportionate to one s work and labour.
"O you who believe! most surely many of the doctors of law and the monks
eat away the property of men falsely, and turn (them) from Allah's way; and (as
for) those who hoard up gold and silver and do not spend it in Allah's way,
announce to them a painful chastisement. On the day when these shall be heated
in the fire of Hell, then their foreheads and their sides and their backs shall
be branded with it; this is what you hoarded up for yourselves, therefore taste
what you hoarded". (al-Tawbah: 34-35).
The conditions for the appointment of judges are very strict and rigorous and
the responsibility of rulers is so great that any true Muslim will shudder to
accept them due to fear of Allah and the Law of Islam. Imam Ail (a.s) warned
Qadi Shurayh that he occupied a seat which was assigned to prophets or their
vicegerents, or occupied by a tyrant. The main objective of the Islamic
government is to estahlish the rule of justice and equity (al-Nahl: 19), which
demands that the weak and the deprived (including slaves) should he provided
their basic needs (al-Nahl: 71). To do justice to the underprivileged seems to
he the most difficult of the jobs of a government, as Imam Ali (a.s) said,
"One who comes to power often oppresses and tyrannizes, and that
"oppression and tyranny are the worst companions in the Hereafte"r.
(Sayings: 198 & 202). (30) As the weaker sections of people fall easy prey
to oppression and tyranny, Islam has taken particular care to guard their
rights and redress whatever their legitimate grievances may he. In this way
Islamic law ensures freedom of the oppressed.
The Qur'an contains a number of verses which lay down the guiding principles of
justice: 1. Never refer to a misled and tyrannical ruler for seeking justice
(al-Nisa': 63, Hud: 113). 2. The prophets and their deputies are made the
vicegerents of God for establishing the rule of justice and equity (Sad: 38).
3. Divinely appointed personages and judges have to follow the commands of God
(al-Ma'idah: 48, 49 & 51). 4. Judges are obliged to see every citizen get
his due (al-Nisa': 61). 5. One has to abide by the order of a judge and an
arbitrator (al-Nur: 48-49, al-Nisa': 68). 6. Judges should be impartial and
meticulous (al-Nisa':106). 7. Judges are bound to admit writs of non-Muslims
and to dispose them at the earliest (al-Ma'idah: 46). 8. Accepting bribes is
strictly prohibited (al-Ba qarah: 180).
The Qur'anic text also lays down the conditions for the appointment of a qadhi:
he ought to be mature, possessing sound reason, of firm faith, just, expert in
fiqh with the ability to do ijtihad, of legitimate birth, free from mental
lapses, and a male. (31) Imam Ali (a.s), in his letter to Malik al-'Ashtar
which is a comprehensive code of conduct for rulers and a document laying down
the Islamic principles of governance and justice, elaborates the Qur'anic code
of conduct by adding that a qadhi has to he intelligent, patient, of stable
temperament, honest, man of integrity, meticulous, and humble. (32) If a judge
is prone to vicissitudes of mood, he cannot judge objectively. Leo Tolstoy, in
the Resurrection, one of his best novels, criticizes and ridicules judges for
being whimsical and moody in delivering judgments, thus committing injustice
and spoiling the lives of innocent people who are at their mercy. He also seems
to confirm the Qur'anic view of not referring to an unjust judge by condemning
the entire legal system based upon vested interests of tyrannical rulers. Imam
Ja'far al-Sadiq (a.s) advised his followers not to appeal to the courts of
unjust and tyrannical rulers who usurped power illegitimately from the rightful
claimants of rulership and directed them to refer among themselves to him who
is an expert on the Qur'anic injunctions and can judge justly. (33) This advice
implies that judgments of an unjust government are not binding on Muslims, and,
implicitly, they are expected to overthrow such a regime. The first and
foremost condition of justice in human social, political, economic, and legal
issues is that the entire socio-political system is to be based on justice. The
rulers usurping power illegitimately and undemocratically in our age cannot
establish the rule of justice. It further implies that the Islamic code of
justice can be implemented in a truly Islamic society and State only. We may
logically infer from this that the States whose rulers are not elected in
accordance with the Islamic criteria have no right to implement the Islamic
laws of retribution (qisas) only, for these laws form an integral part of the
whole Islamic superstructure. The principle of justice demands that it is the
first duty of a ruler claiming to follow the Islamic polity to build a truly
Islamic society conducive to the implementation of Islamic justice.
Another significant point made by Imam Ali (a.s) in his letter to Malik
al-'Ashtar anticipates a modern principle of democratic rule, which was
realized in the West in the present century only:
"Pay them (qadhis) handsomely so that their needs are fully satisfied and
they are not required to beg or borrow or resort to corruption. Give them such
a prestige and position in your province that none of your officers or
courtiers can overlord them or bring harm to them. Let judiciary be above every
kind of executive pressure or influence, above fear or favour, intrigue or
corruption". (34)
Most probably, the importance of independence of the judiciary was realized for
the first time by Imam Ali (a.s) in the annals of human history. He regarded it
to be an essential condition of the administration of justice. His great
concern for the weaker and oppressed sections of society is evident throughout
his sermons, letters, admonitions, and directives issued to his military and
administrative officers, and judges.
His concern was the honesty and integrity of persons as the basic condition in
the appointment of all officers from the lowest rank up to the highest. If
officers, particularly judges, are corrupt or prone to temptations, the
stronger sections will be able to deprive the weak of their rights. Advising
his governors to hold regular public audiences, he commands them not to let
guards and police officers be present on such occasions, so that those who have
grievances against the government may speak to the Amir freely, unreservedly,
and without fear. (35) At the same time he reminds them that in such audience
mostly the common people will gather: Therefore, if you find them misbehaving,
or acting in an unmannerly fashion, or if you feel that their talk is
irrelevant, tolerate them; do not be rude and insulting to them ... (36)
He adds that he often heard the Prophet (s.a.w) saying: "A nation or
government in which the rights of the depressed, the destitute, and the
suppressed are not guarded and where the mighty and the powerful persons are
not forced to accede these rights, cannot succeed". (37)
With a view to preventing any possibility of oppression and exploitation, he
prohibits giving of lands on permanent lease with all property and ownership
rights and water supply and other sources of public utility to anybody, because
such possessions will enable privileged persons to oppress others and derive
undue advantage. (38)
Amir al-Mu'minin's regard for the judiciary and proper legal procedure made him
to appear in the court of Qadhi Shurayh as a complainant. When the qadhi
offered him a seat of honour, he reproached him for being discriminate. He
accepted the judgment against himself, though his claim was right. The opposite
party was a Christian, who was so impressed by Ali's submission to the court of
law that he confessed that he had no claim on the disputed property; he also
volunteered to embrace Islam. Here another aspect of Amir al-Mumini's adherence
to Islamic teachings comes to light. He repeatedly enquired if he was forced by
somebody to give up his old faith. When he was convinced that there was no compulsion
by any authority and the Christian wished to embrace Islam willingly and
freely, only then he taught him the kalimah. (39)
It was under such rulers that Muslims learnt to respect freedom and rights of
all human beings including those of non-Muslims.
The Enemies of Islam as Depicted in the Nahjul Balagha
They deserved the revolution which overtook them. They were destroyed and
annihilated, and the people were rescued from calamities and destruction, were
relieved of war, and bloodshed, which were brought about by the tyrants.
"The pious people, who bravely passed through those days, patiently bore
the suffering and gave their lives for the cause of justice and Islam. They
humbled themselves, before God, they never for a moment magnified their patience
and bravery and never imagined that they were obliging God and His religion.
Then God ordained that the times of trials and tribulations should come to an
end. They were given permission to defend their faith with the help of their
swords and they obeyed the orders of God according to the teaching of the Holy
Prophet(AS).
"Things continued like that until God called the Prophet back. Then many
became apostate, or turned to heathenism, they were damned by the preversity of
their minds and waywardness. They put faith in their relatives, who were
misguided, or in instigators who were heathens. They discarded the medium (the
progeny of the Prophet), whom they were ordered to love, to respect and to
follow, and who would have kept them within the limits of the true religion.
Thus, they undermined the foundation of the true religion and tried to
introduce heresy in Islam. They adopted the ways of the Pharoahs and his
people, were attached to worldly power and pleasures, and drifted away from
true religion."
Sermon (Khutba) 153
"O people! remember that the present time is the time when something which
has been promised will happen, and events which you do not know or cannot
forsee will take place. During the days of trials and temptations, those who
recognize the significance and worth of the Ahlul-Bayt will, like a person
walking in the dark with a lamp in his hand, not only go safely through the
times, but will be of help to others and will act like pious people. This will
free the people from oppression and tyranny , will educate the ill-informed and
ignorant, will introduce reforms into society, and will cement the gaps which
wickedness and impiety may have created in the true teachings of Islam. For
some time, he (i.e. Imam Mahdi) will be hidden from the eyes of man in such a
way that the great searcher of the day will not be able to find a trace of him
however he may try.
But when he will appear, he will educate mankind in such a way that human
vision will expand through the teachings of the Quran, men will be able to
acquire true wisdom, and their minds will be able to rise to higher planes of
science and philosophy."
I strongly urge Muslims to reject any false myths about our Islamic heritage.
Many of you already know the Sunni view of history. I strongly urge you to read
the Sunni works in history such as of al-Tabari, and Syed Amir Ali, to
understand the forces that shaped the Muslim world in the 1st century AH. They
are still alive and kicking today.
The Genuineness and Authenticity
of Nahj al-Balagha
The first person to raise doubts about its attribution to Amir al-Mu'minin was
Ibn Khallikan (d. 681/1282), who, without referring to any author or
source,made the following remarks about the authorship of Nahj al-Balaghah:
People have different opinions about the compiler of Nahj al- Balaghah, a
collection of the utterances of al-'Imam 'Ali ibn Abi Talib (as) There is
difference as to whether it was compiled by al-Sharif al-Murtada or his brother
al-Radi. It is also said that it is not at all the composition of 'Ali (as) and
that the one who compiled it and attributed it to him made it himself; but
Allah knows the truth.
These remarks were made in Wafayat al-aya'n in connection with the account of
the life and work of al-Sharif al-Murtada, al-Radi's elder brother. Ibn
al-'Athir al Jazari (555-630/1160-1232) in Mukhtasar al-Wafayat, Salah al-Din
al-Safadi (d. 764/1362) in al-Wafi bi al-wafayat, al-'Allamah al-Yafi'i(d.
768/1366) in Mir'at al Jinan, and Ibn al-'Imad in Shadharat al-dhahab were
content just to repeat Ibn Khallikan's conjecture without bothering to
substantiate it. Al-'Allamah al-Dhahabi (d. 748/1347) in Mizan ul-'i'tidal was
the first person to pick up the audacity to raise the unfounded doubt to a
degree of certainty a century after Ibn Khallikan.
He wrote in his account of al-Murtada:
Al Sharif al-Murtada, who is accused of fabricating Nahj al- Balaghah, was a
scholar of considerable knowledge. Whosoever sees his book Nahj al-Balaghah
would come to believe that it was falsely attributed to Amir al-Mu'minin (as),
because it contains open abuse rather than downgrading of the two caliphs Abu
Bakr and 'Umar. Contradictions and mean matters have also crept into it, which
do not conform with the spirit of the Companions of the Quraysh and our knowledge
of the later Companions. One is convinced that the major part of this book is
forged and unauthentic.
Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani (d. 748/1347) repeated al-Dhahabi's objections without
bothering to probe deeper into the matter.
The most interesting and at the same time the weakest part of the objections
concerns ascription of the authorship of Nahj al-Balaghah to al-Murtada.
The objectors belonged to the Umayyad West and had deep prejudices against
Shiii scholars, and perhaps under the impact of Umayyad propaganda their
prejudice was so deep-rooted that even their scholarship could not rise above
it.
Among the four contemporaries of al-Radi and al-Murtada, three, that is,
al-Tha'alibi, al-Najashi (d. 450/1058), and al-Khatib al-Baghdadi (d. 463/1071)
have given accounts of both the brothers.
Al Shaykh al-Tusi did not give any account of al-Radi in al-Fihrist or
al-Rijal, but he did not count Nahj al-Balagha among the works of al-Murtada,
which dispel any conjecture attributing its authorship to him, because al-Tusi
was very close to him as his student. Al-Tha'alibi and al-Khatib al-Baghdadi
did not mention Nahj al-Balaghah either in the account of al-Murtada or that of
al-Radi.Al-Najashi in unambiguous terms attributed Nahj al-Balagha to al-Radi.
Al-Tusi's exclusion of Nahj al-Balaghah from the works of al-Murtada,and
al-Najashi's mention of it among the works of al-Radi are sufficient to prove
that it was without any doubt a work of al-Radi.
The objectors, who could not even determine authorship of the book exactly,
depended on nothing but their whim to raise doubts about its authenticity.
A more convincing proof of al-Radi's authorship of Nahj al-Balaghah can be
found in his own other works in which he has mentioned it. Those books are the
following:
1. Khasa'is al- 'A'immah: A manuscript of this work of al-Radi is in Rida
Library Rampur (India) which reveals that Fadl Allah ibn 'Ali al- Husayn
al-Rawandi (d. 555/1160) accepted Khasa'is as al-Radi's work. In this book, as
quoted above, al-Radi has mentioned his intention of compiling Nahj
al-Balaghah.
2. Haqa'iq al-tanzil: Only the fifth part of this book is accessible to us. Its
authorship is unanimously attributed to al-Radi. On page 167 of this book
al-Radi makes this remark:
Anybody who needs a proof of our claim should refer to our book Nahj
al-Balaghah and think upon its contents. We have compiled all forms and genres
of the utteranees of Amir al-Mu'minin (as) in this book, which comprises
sermons, letters, aphorisms, and admonitions, and is divided into three
independent parts, each containing a specific genre.
3. Majazat al-'athar al-Nabawiyyah: Al-Najashi and others have included this
book among al-Radi's works. At two places in this book al-Radi has referred to
Nah; al-Balagha as a work of his own compilation.
It is important to note that even Ibn Khallikan, al-Dhahabi and Ibn Hajar did
not question the authenticity of the attribution of Nahj al-Balaghah in its
entirety to'Ali (as). They were mainly skeptical of those parts which were
critical of the Caliphs Abu Bakr and 'Umar.
But if we find such utterances and writings of Amir al-Mu'minin (as) in both
Shi'i and non-Shi'i sources earlier than Nahjal-Balaghah, baselessness of
al-Dhahabi's and Ibn Hajar's objections can be conclusively proved.
Let us again refer to Istinad-e Nahj al-Balagha by 'Arshi, a contemporary Sunni
scholar of India. With respect to the harshest of the sermons concerning the
issue of the caliphate, known as al-Khutbat al-Shiqshiiyyah, 'Arshi refers to
the following early sources in which the sermon had occurred:
1. Abu Ja'far Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Khalid al-Barqi (d.274/887) has quoted it
in full in al-Mahasin wa al-'adab.
2. Ibrahim ibn Muhammad al-Thaqafi al-Kufi (d. 283/896) quoted it in al-Gharat.
In his notes on al-Gharat, Sayyid Jalal al-Din Muhaddith,quoting Imtiyaz 'Ali
Khan 'Arshi, says that this khutbah is not found in it; even Ibn Abi al-Hadid
and al-'Allamah Muhammad Baqir al-Majlisi (1037-1110 or 1111/1627-1698 or 99)
did not refer to al-Gharat as an early source of this sermon.
3. Abu 'Ali Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab al Jubba'i al-Basri al-Mu'tazili(d.
303/915 -16) narrated it.
4. Abu Ja'far Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-Rahman ibn Qubbah al-Razi (a teacher of al-
Mufid and a pupil of Abu al-Qasim al-Balkhi, a Mu'tazili in his youth) quoted
it in al-Insaf.
5. Abu al Qasim 'Abd Allah ibn Ahmad ibn Mahmud al-Ka'bi al-Balkhi al-Mu'tazili
(d. 319/931) in al-'Insaf.
6. Abu Ja'far Muhammad ibn 'Ali ibn al-Husayn ibn Musa ibn Babawayh al-Qummi,
known as al-Shaykh al-Saduq (d. 318/930), has quoted it in two of his books:
Ilal al Sharayi' and Ma'ani al-'akhbar.
7. Abu 'Abd Allah Muhammad ibn al-Nu'man, known as al-Shaykh al-Mufid(d. 413/
1022) in Kitdb al-'irshad.
8. Shaykh al-Ta'ifah Abu Ja'far Muhammad ibn al-Hasan al-Tusi (d. 460/1068) in
al-'Amali.
'Arshi adds that al Shaykh al Saduq has narrated this Khutbah on the authority
of two different chains of narrators:
Narrated to us Muhammad ibn 'Ali Majalawayh from his uncle Muhammad Ibn
al-Qasim, he from Ahmad ibn 'Abd Allah al-Barqi he from his father, he from Ibn
Abi 'Umayr, he from Aban ibn 'Uthman he from 'Aban ibn Taghlib, he from
'Ikrimah, he from 'Abd Allah ibn al-'Abbas. ('Ilal al-sharayi' and Ma'anial-'
akhbar)
Narrated to us Muhammad ibn Ibrahim ibn Ishaq al-Taliqani, from 'Abd al-'Aziz
ibn Yahya al Jalludi, from Abu 'Abd Allah Ahmad ibn 'Ammar ibn Khalid, from
Yahya ibn 'Abd al-Hamid al- Hammani, from 'Isa ibn Rashid, from 'Ali ibn
Khuzaymah, from 'Ikrimah, from Ibn al-'Abbas. (Ma'ani al 'akhbar)
Al-Sayyid al-Radi has not quoted the entire chain of narrators, and was content
to remark that the sermon was popularly known as 'al-Shiqshiqiyyah ', while his
teacher al-Mufid narrates both the chain of narrators and the story behind its
narration. This is indicative of the fact that this sermon was so famous in
those days that al-Radi did not find it necessary to prove its veracity by
quoting the chain of its narrators. Surprisingly, the same famous sermon was
used by his and 'Ali's opponents to question his veracity and to malign him by
accusing him and/or his brother of forging it. The kind of criticism Ibn
Khallikan and his followers dabbled in not only discredits them as researchers
but also makes their other works suspicious in the eyes of impartial and
objective students of history.
Those who could not find any of the above-mentioned books to cross-check the
veracity of Nahj al-Balaghah had failed miserably even in determining correctly
its authorship.
Al-Shaykh al-Mufid has collected a number of 'Ali's speeches in al-'Irshad
concerning the issue of the succession to the Prophet (saw) and 'Ali's
criticism of the ways and means adopted by his opponents to deprive him of the
caliphate. The famous Khutbah known as al-Shiq-shiqiyyah begins with the
following preface:
(A group of traditionists report by a variety of chains of authority (turuq) on
the authority of Ibn al-'Abbas, who said:)
I [i.e. Ibn al-'Abbas, was with the Commander of the Faithful at al-Rahabah I
mentioned the [matter of] Caliphate and those who had preeeded him. He breathed
heavily and said: "By God, Ibn Abi Quhatah took on...."
This khutbah ends with the following words:
Then you would have found that your world is more insignificant in my eyes than
a goat's snot.
At this point 'Ali's speech was interrupted by a man from Kufah. Ibn al-'Abbas,
after narrating the text of the speech, adds:
I have never regretted anything nor felt such distress like the distress l felt
at losing the rest of the speeeh of the Commander of the Faithful, peace be on
him. When he finished reading the letter, I said: "Commander of the
Faithful would you continue your speech from the point which you reached?"
He answered: "In no way, in no way. It was like foam on the camel's mouth
(shiqshiqah) as it opens its mouth to bellow and then falls silent."
Apart from al-'Irshad this khutbah, as claimed by 'Arshi, is found in other
sources also. In no way can it be dubbed as al-Radi's or al-Murtada's
fabrication. Sayyid Hibat al-Din al-Shahristani, in Mahuwa Nahj al-Balaghah,
has quoted different versions of al-Khutbat al-Shiqshiqiyyah from:
Nathral-durar wa nuzhat al-'adab by the vizier Abu Sa'id al-'Abi; al-'Irshad by
al- Shaykh ai-Mufid; al-Mahasin wa al-'adab by al-Barqi; al-Saduq in Ila'l
al-sharayi';and a book of al-Jalludi. All the versions have minor differences,
which indicate that the source from which al-Radi quoted this sermon was other
than these four. After enumerating the earlier works containing this
khutbah,Hibat al-Din al- Shahristani points out that Ibn 'Abd Rabbih, one of
tbe compilers of al-Khutbat al-Shiqshiqiyyah, was a follower of the Banu
Umayyah and a staunch admirer of the third caliph 'Uthman ibn writes:
'Affan. Much earlier than Ibn Khallikan made his remark questioning the
authenticity of the attribution of Nahj al- Balaghah, certain doubts had come
to circulate as indicated by Ibn Abi al-Hadid al-Mu'tazili (d. 555/1257), who
referred to a discussion concerning the attribution of al-Khutbat al-
Shiqshiqiyyah with his teacher Abu al-Khayr Musaddiq ibn Shabib [sic. Shayb]
al-Wasiti (d. 605/1208), who said:
I read this khutbah in the presenee of Abu Muhammad 'Abd Allah ibn Ahmad, known
as Ibn al-Khashshab (493 -567/1099-1172)... and asked him if he considered this
khutbah to be a forged one and not of 'Ali (as). Ibn al-Khashshab said:
By God, I am convinced that it is from 'Ali and I am as sure of it as I am
convineed of your truthfulness.
Al-Wasiti said to Ibn al-Khashshab: "A group is of the view that this
khutbah was fabricated by al-Radi, may God be pleased with him." Ibn
al-Khashshab said:
Is it not beyond the eloquence of al-Radi or any other? How could he speak from
such a high level of spirituality in such a (forceful) style? We are well
acquainted with al-Radi's writings, his style and his technique. I have
assessed both his poetry and prose, these words as compared to those of al-
Radi are so different that there is no question of confusing them with his
writings."
He further said:
By God, I have read this sermon in books written two hundred years before the
birth of al-Radi. Yes, of course, I have seen it written in many books. I can
identify this khutbah very well and know that which of the 'ulama' and men of
letters quoted it (in his work) mueh before al-Radi's father was born."
(Sharh Nahj al-Balaghah, vol. I)
On another occasion, in his Sharh Nahj al-Balaghah, Ibn Abi al-Hadid
A group of blind followers of their own whims and wishes is of the opinion that
the best part of Nahj al-Balagha is fabricated and forged by a group of Shi'i
writers and is something new. Most of them consider a part of it to be the
product of al-Radi's pen or of others. But this group consists of prejudiced
people, whose heart's vision is blocked by partiality and who have deviated
from the right and straight path of truth; they have strayed from truth due to
perversion, lack of knowledge, and unfamiliarity with literature and poetry.
(vol. 1, p. 543)
At another place he writes about the words of Amir al-Mu'minin (as):
His eloquence is such that he is the leader of the eloquent and the guide and
master of orators. It is said about his utterances that his words are below the
Word of the Creator only, but over and above the words of all creatures; and
from him the world has learnt the art of speech and rhetoric.
There were people in the age of al-Radi himself whose hearts and eyes were
sealed in such a manner that they attributed some of 'Ali's utterances to
Mu'aiwiyah. Al-Radi's commentary on the following khutbah,is important:
His comment, are as follows:
People with no ability to understand literature ascribe it to Mu'awiyah whereas
these are undoubtedly the words of Amir al- Mu'minin. How can dirt compare with
pure gold?... 'Amr ibn Bahr al Jahiz, a critic gifted with insight and a
distinct sensibility, has probed the matter minutely. He has included this
khutbah in al-Bayan wa al-tabyin, and has mentioned those who attributed it to
Mu'awiyah. Subsequently he says: "This speech is very much like the
speeches of 'Ali (as) and is in conformity with the great man's classification
of people, and it also corresponds with his manner of depicting the people's
modes of behaving in anger, under oppression and waywardness, and in the state
of dissimulation and fear.
Similarly, al-Radi refers to his sources on a number of occasions, and also
gives an account of the circumstances that were responsible for the mood and
theme of a certain sermon. He has referred to: al Jahiz; al-Waqidi; Abu Ja'far
al-'Iskafi; Hisham ibn al-Kalbi; Sa'id ibn Yahya ai-'Umawi, the author of
al-Maghazi; Abu 'Ubayd al- Qasim ibn Salam; al-Tabari; Tha'lab; Ibn al-'A'rabi;
al-Mubarrad, and many others. How could an author who allegedly forged the
utterances and writings of Amir al- Mu'minin (as) be so honest in acknowledging
his indebtedness to his predecessors?
Those who raised doubts about the contents of Nahj al-Balagha were unaware of
the high status and prestige of its compiler, both in the society and in the
academic circles. A man of his eminence could not even think of fabricating
sermons and letters in the name of al-'Imam 'Ali (as).
Had any such attempt been made by anybody, Shi'i scholars themselves would have
been the first to reject it, as an anthology of poetry attributed to al-'Imam
'Ali (as) (Diwan-e 'Ali) was never accepted by the majority of Shi'i scholars
as authentic. Some other such works, for example, the commentary on the Quran
attributed to al- Imam al-Hasan al-'Askari (as) or Fiqh al-Reza attributed to
al Imam al-Reza (as),are at issue among Shi'i scholars. But no one among
al-Radi's contemporaries or from the successive generations of Sunni or Shi'i
'ulama' ever questioned Nahj al-Balaghah's authenticity for more than two
centuries.
Regarding the contents of Nahj al-Balaghah the Muslim scholars of all shades of
opinion never doubted al-Radi's veracity.
They were aware of the presence of earlier sources of al-'Imam 'Ali's
utterances. There is abundant reliable evidence in support of the existence of
such collections in the first and second centuries of Hijrah, from which 'Abd
al-Hamid ibn Yahyfi, Ibn al- Muqaffa', and Zayd ibn 'Ali ibn al-Husayn ibn 'Ali
ibn Abi Talib had quoted al-'Imam 'Ali's sermons and letters.
In the third and fourth centuries, too, several collections of 'Ali's khutab
and rasa'il were compiled, some of which have been already referred to above.
Ibn Abi al-Hadid (d. 655 or 656/1257 or 58); Taqi al-Din Ahmad, known as Ibn
Taymiyyah (661-728/1263-1328); and his pupil Salah al-Din al-Safadi (d.764/1362
-63) accepted Nahj al-Balaghah as a genuine collection of al Imam 'Ali's words.
The former not only wrote one of the most famous commentaries on it, but also
repudiated all doubts about its authenticity.
Ibn Taymiyyah and al-Safadi were among staunch opponents and critics of the
Shi'ah, but both of them verified the authenticity of Nahj al-Balagha and the
veracity of al-Sharif al-Radi. Al-Safadi, in the account of al-Radi, writes:
People are of the view that Nahj al-Balaghah is his own writing. But I heard my
teacher, al-'Imam al-'Allamah Taqi al-Din Ahmad ibn Taymiyyah say: "Nahj
al-Balaghah is not al-Sayyid al-Radi's product. What in this book is the
utterance of 'Ali ibn Abi Talib (as) is known, and whatever is from al-Radi
that is also known. (al-Wafi bi al-wafayat, vol. 2, p. 375)
Instead of going into further details of the controversy about the authenticity
of Nahj al-Balaghah's ascription and forwarding more evidence against those who
created doubts about it, I would recommend the keen reader to consult al-Mu'jam
al-mufahras li alfaz Nahj al-Balaghah, edited by al-Sayyid Kazim al-Muhammadi
and al-Shaykh Muhammad al-Dashti, who have done a commendable job in preparing
a very comprehensive bibliography of the sources of the book along with a
detailed item- by-item list of the sources of each and every sermon, letter, and
saying contained in Nahj al-Balaghah. Moreover, since the death of al-Radi
scholars of eminence have been always interested in writing commentaries on
Nahj al-Balagha, which is another very strong proof of its authenticity. So
many Sunni, Mu'tazili, and Shi'i scholars would not have taken pains to comment
upon al Radi's own fabrications.
'Ali Naqi Munzawi, in the catalogue of the library of Mishkat, donated to
Tehran University, has enumerated 33 narrators of al-'Imam 'Ali's utterances
before al-Radi and fourteen after him till the tenth Hijrah century. Danish
Pizhoh, in his preface to Farman-e Malik Ashtar, edited by Husayn 'Alawi Awi,
has given a list of its early commentators. Sayyid 'Abd al-Zahra' al-Khatib, in
Masadir Nahj al-Balagha wa asaniduh, has counted thirty-three books written
concerning the sources of Nahj al-Balaghah. Hundreds of manuscripts of Nahj
al-Balaghah in various libraries of the world and even a greater number of the
manuscripts of other earlier works containing al-'Imam 'Ali's utterances invite
all seekers of truth to trace the sources and ascertain the authenticity of
Nahj al-Balaghah. There are also numerous documents available which contain
certificates and testimonials issued by eminent scholars to their pupils
authorizing them to narrate the contents of Nahj al-Balaghah along with the
permission to narrate ahadith of the Prophet (saw) and the Imams (as).
This is enough to show that Nahj al-Balaghah has been considered to be of equal
value in reliability with the most authentic compendiums of hadith. The
narration of Nahj al-balagha's traditions had started during the lifetime of
al-Radi. Qutb al-Din al-Rawandi (d. 573/1177) in the preface of his commentary
on Nahj al-Balaghoh, refers to a daughter of al-Sharif al Murtada, who had
studied the book under al-Radi himself and was authorized to narrate its
traditions to others, and she used to narrate Nahj al-Balaghah on her uncle's
authority. Shaykh 'Abd al-Rahim al-Baghdadi has narrated from this learned lady
of the family of the Imams
Imam Ali's Letter to Malik Ashtar
This script reads: "Ali Ibn Abi Talib, radiya' llah Ta'aala anhu
wa-Karrama wajhahu." (Ali Bin Abi Talib, may God Almighty be pleased with
him and honor him.) The script is Tawqi', structured into the shape of a lion.
The Richest Treasure
The Common Man
The Counselors
The Different Classes of People
The Army
The Real Guidance
Chief Judge
Subordinate Judiciary
Revenue Administration
Clerical Establishment
Trade and Industry
The Poor
Open Conferences
Communion with God
Aloofness not Desirable
Peace and Treaties
Last Instructions
The Richest Treasure
Be it known to you, O, Malik, that I am sending you as Governor to a country
which in the past has experienced both just and unjust rule. Men will
scrutinize your actions with a searching eye, even as you used to scrutinize
the actions of those before you, and speak of you even as you did speak of
them. The fact is that the public speak well of only those who do good. It is
they who furnish the proof of your actions. Hence the richest treasure that you
may covet would be the treasure of good deeds. Keep your desires under control
and deny yourself that which you have been prohibited from, for, by such
abstinence alone, you will be able to distinguish between what is good to them
and what is not.
Develop in your heart the feeling of love for your people and let it be the source of kindliness and blessing to them. Do not behave with them like a barbarian, and do not appropriate to yourself that which belongs to them. Remember that the citizens of the state are of two categories. They are either your brethren in religion or your brethren in kind. They are subject to infirmities and liable to commit mistakes. Some indeed do commit mistakes. But forgive them even as you would like God to forgive you. Bear in mind that you are placed over them, even as I am placed over you. And then there is God even above him who has given you the position of a Governor in order that you may look after those under you and to be sufficient unto them. And you will be judged by what you do for them.
Do not set yourself against God, for neither do you possess the strength to shield yourself against His displeasure, nor can you place yourself outside the pale of His mercy and forgiveness. Do not feel sorry over any act of forgiveness, nor rejoice over any punishment that you may mete out to any one. Do not rouse yourself to anger, for no good will come out of it.
Do not say: " I am your overlord and dictator, and that you should, therefore, bow to my commands", as that will corrupt your heart, weaken your faith in religion and create disorder in the state. Should you be elated by power, ever feel in your mind the slightest symptoms of pride and arrogance, then look at the power and majesty of the Divine governance of the Universe over which you have absolutely no control. It will restore the sense of balance to your wayward intelligence and give you the sense of calmness and affability. Beware! Never put yourself against the majesty and grandeur of God and never imitate His omnipotence; for God has brought low every rebel of God and every tyrant of man.
Let your mind respect through your actions the rights of God and the rights of man, and likewise, persuade your companions and relations to do likewise. For, otherwise, you will be doing injustice to yourself and injustice to humanity. Thus both man and God will turn unto your enemies. There is no hearing anywhere for one who makes an enemy of God himself. He will be regarded as one at war with God until he feels contrition and seeks forgiveness. Nothing deprives man of divine blessings or excites divine wrath against him more easily than cruelty. Hence it is, that God listens to the voice of the oppressed and waylays the oppressor.
The Common Man
Maintain justice in administration and impose it on your own self and seek the consent of the people, for, the discontent of the masses sterilizes the contentment of the privileged few and the discontent of the few looses itself in the contentment of the many. Remember the privileged few will not rally round you in moments of difficulty: they will try to side-track justice, they will ask for more than what they deserve and will show no gratitude for favors done to them. They will feel restive in the face of trials and will offer no regret for their shortcomings. It is the common man who is the strength of the State and Religion. It is he who fights the enemy. So live in close contact with the masses and be mindful of their welfare.
Keep at a distance him who peers into the weaknesses of others. After all, the masses are not free from weaknesses. It is the duty of the ruler to shield them. Do not bring to light that which is hidden, but try to remove those weaknesses which have been brought to light. God is watchful of everything that is hidden from you, and He alone will deal with it. To the best of your ability cover the weaknesses of the public, and God will cover the weaknesses in you which you are anxious to keep away from their eye. Unloose the tangle of mutual hatred between the public and the administration and remove all those causes which may give rise to strained relations between them. Protect yourself from every such act as may not be quite correct for you. Do not make haste in seeking confirmation of tale-telling, for, the tale-teller is a deceitful person appearing in the garb of a friend.
The Counselors
Never take counsel of a miser, for he will vitiate your magnanimity and frighten you of poverty. Do not take counsel of a coward also, for, he will cheat you of your resolves. Do not take counsel of the greedy too: for he will instill greed in you and turn you into a tyrant. Miserliness, cowardice and greed deprive man of his trust in God.
The worst of counselors is he who has served as a counselor to unjust rulers and shared their crimes. So, never let men who have been companions of tyrants or shared their crimes be your counselors. You can get better men than these, men gifted with intelligence and foresight, but unpolluted by sin, men who have never aided a tyrant in his tyranny or a criminal in his crime. Such men will never be a burden on you. On the other hand, they will be a source of help and strength to you at all times. They will be friends to you and strangers to your enemies. Choose such men alone for companionship both in privacy and in the public. Even among these, show preference to them who have a habitual regard for truth however trying to you at times their truth may prove to be, and who offer you no encouragement in the display of tendencies which God does not like his friends to develop.
Keep close to you the upright, and the God fearing, and make clear to them that they are never to flatter you and never to give you credit for any good that you may not have done: for, the tolerance of flattery and unhealthy praise stimulates pride in man makes him arrogant.
Do not treat the good and the bad alike. That will deter the good from doing good, and encourage the bad in their bad pursuits. Recompense every one according one's deserts. Remember that mutual trust and good will between the ruler and the ruled are bred only through benevolence, justice and service. So, cultivate good-will amongst the people; for their good-will alone will save you from troubles. Your benevolence to them will be repaid by their trust in you, and your ill-treatment by their ill-will.
Do not disregard the noble traditions set by our forbearers which have promoted harmony and progress among the people; and do not initiate anything which might minimize their usefulness. The men who had established these noble traditions have had their reward; but responsibility will be yours if they are disturbed. Try always to learn something from the experience of the learned and the wise, and frequently consult them in state matters so that you might maintain the peace and good-will which your predecessors had established in the land.
The Different Classes of People
Remember that the people are composed of different classes. The progress of one is dependent on the progress of every other; and none can afford to be independent of the other. We have the Army formed of the soldiers of God, we have our civil officers and their establishments, our judiciary, our revenue collectors and our public relation officers. The general public itself consists of Muslims and Zimmis and among them of merchants and craftsmen, the unemployed and the indigent. God has prescribed for them their several rights, duties and obligations. They are all defined and preserved in the Book of God and in the traditions of his Prophet.
The army, by the grace of God, is like a fortress to the people and lends dignity to the state. It upholds the prestige of the Faith and maintains the peace of the country. Without it the state cannot stand. In its turn, it cannot stand without the support of the state. Our soldiers have proved strong before the enemy because of the privilege God has given them to fight for Him; but they have their material needs to fulfil and have therefore to depend upon the income provided for them from the state revenue. The military and civil population who pay revenue, both need the co-operation of others -the judiciary, civil officers and their establishment. The Qazi administers civil and criminal law; the civil officers collect revenue and attend to civil administration with the assistance of their establishment. And then there are the tradesmen and the merchants who add to the revenue of the state. It is they who run the markets and are in a better position than others to discharge social obligations. And then there is the class of the poor and the needy, whose maintenance is an obligation on the other classes. God has given appropriate opportunity of service to one and all; and then there are the rights of all these classes over the administration which the administrator has to meet with an eye on the good of the entire population, a duty which he cannot fulfill properly unless he takes personal interest in its execution and seeks help from God. Indeed it is obligatory on him to impose this duty on himself and to bear with patience the inconveniences and difficulties incidental to his task.
The Army
Be particularly mindful of the welfare of those in the army who in your opinion, are staunchly faithful to their God and Prophet and loyal to their chief, and who in the hour of passion can restrain themselves and listen coolly to sensible remonstrance, and who can succor the weak and smite the strong, whom violent provocation will not throw into violent temper and who will not falter at any stage.
Keep yourself in close contact with the families of established reputation and integrity with a glorious past, and draw to yourself men brave and upright in character, generous and benevolent in disposition; for such are the salt of society.
Care for them with the tenderness with which you care for your children, and do not talk before them of any good that you might have done to them, nor disregard any expression of affection which they show in return; for, such conduct inspires loyalty, devotion and goodwill. Attend to every little of their wants not resting content with what general help that you might have given to them, for sometimes, timely attention to a little want of theirs brings them immense relief. Surely these people will not forget you in your own hour of need.
It behooves you to select for your Commander-in-chief one who imposes on himself as a duty, the task of rendering help to his men, and who can excel in kindness every other officer who has to attend to the needs of the men under him, and look after their families when they are away from their homes; so much so, that the entire army should feel united in their joys and in their sorrows. The unity of purpose will give them added strength against the enemy. Continue to maintain a kindly attitude towards them so that they might feel attached to you. The fact is that the real happiness of the administrators and their most pleasant comfort lies in establishing justice in the state and maintaining affectionate relations with the people. Their sincerity of feeling is expressed in the love and regard they show to you, on which alone depends the safety of the administrators.
Your advices to the army will be of no avail, unless and until you show affection to both men and officers, in order that they might not regard the Government as an oppressive burden or contribute to its downfall.
Continue to satisfy their needs and praise them over and over again for what services they have rendered. Such an attitude, God willing will inspire the brave to braver actions and induce the timid to deeds of bravery.
Try to enter into the feelings of others and do not foist the mistake of one over another and do not grudge dispensing appropriate rewards. See to it you do not show favors to one who has done nothing but merely counts on his family position; and do not withhold proper rewards from one who has done great deeds simply because he holds a low position in life.
The Real Guidance
Turn to God and to His prophet for guidance whenever you feel uncertain as to what you have to do. There is the commandment of God delivered to those people who He wishes to guide aright: "O people of the Faith! Obey God and obey His prophet and those from among you who hold authority over you. And refer to God and His prophet whenever there is difference of opinion among you. To turn to God is in reality to consult the Book of God; and to turn to the prophet is t follow his universally accepted traditions.
Chief Judge
Select for your chief judge one from the people who is by far the best among them -one who is not obsessed with domestic worries, one who cannot be intimidated, one who does not err to often, one who does not turn back from a right path once he finds it, one who is not self-centered or avaricious, one who will not decide before knowing full facts, one who will weigh wit care every attendant doubt and pronounce a clear verdict after taking everything into full consideration, one who will not grow restive over the arguments of advocates and who will examine with patience every new disclosure of fact and who will be strictly impartial in his decision, one who flattery cannot mislead or one who does not exult over his position. But it is not easy to find such men.
Once you have selected the right man for the office, pay him handsomely enough, to let him live in comfort and in keeping with his position, enough to keep him above temptations. Give him a position in your court so high none can even dream of coveting it and so high that neither back-biting nor intrigue can touch him.
Subordinate Judiciary
Beware! The utmost carefulness is to be exercised in his selection: for it is this high office which adventurous self-seekers aspire to secure and exploit in their selfish interests. After the selection of your chief judge, give careful consideration to the selection of other officers. Confirm them in their appointments after approved apprenticeship and probation. Never select men for responsible posts either out of any regard for personal connections or under any influence, for, that might lead to injustice and corruption.
Of these select for higher posts men of experience, men firm in faith and belonging to good families. Such men will not fall an easy prey to temptations and will discharge their duties with an eye on the abiding good of others. Increase their salaries to give them a contented life. A contented living is a help to self-purification. They will not feel the urge to tax the earnings of their subordinates for their own upkeep. They will then have no excuse either to go against your instructions or misappropriate state funds. Keep to watch over them without their knowledge, loyal and upright men. Perchance they may develop true honesty and true concern for the public welfare. But whenever any of them is accused of dishonesty and the guilt is confirmed by the report of your secret service, then regard this as a sufficient to convict him. Let the punishment be corporal and let that be dealt in the public at an appointed place of degradation.
Revenue Administration
Great care is to be exercised in revenue administration, to ensure the prosperity of those who pay the revenue to the state; for it is on their prosperity depends the prosperity of others, particularly the prosperity of the masses. Indeed, the state exists on its revenue. You should regard the proper upkeep of the land in cultivation as of greater importance than the collection of revenue, for revenue cannot be derived except by making the land productive. He who demands revenue without helping the cultivator to improve his land, inflicts unmerited hardship on the cultivator and ruins the State. The rule of such a person does not last long. If the cultivators ask for reduction of their land cess for having suffered from epidemics or drought or excess of rains or the barrenness of the soil or floods damaging to their barrenness of the soil or foods damaging to their crops, then, reduce the cess accordingly, so that their condition might improve. Do not mind the loss of revenue on that account for that will return to you one day manifold in the hour of greater prosperity of the land and enable you to improve the condition of your towns and to raise the prestige of your state. You will be the object of universal praise. The people will believe in your sense of justice. The confidence which they will place in you in consequence will prove your strength, as they will be found ready to share your burdens.
You may settle down on the land any number of people, but discontent will overtake them if the land is not improved. The cause of the cultivator's ruin is the rulers who are bent feverishly on accumulating wealth at all costs, out of the fear that their rule might not last long. Such are the people who do not learn from examples or precedents.
Clerical Establishment
Keep an eye on your establishment and your scribes; and select the best among them for your confidential correspondence such among these as possess high character and deserve your full confidence, men who may not exploit their privileged position to go against you and who may not grow neglectful of their duties and who in the drafting of treaties may not succumb to external temptation and harm your interests, or fail to render you proper assistance and to save you from trouble, and who in carrying out their duties can realize their serious responsibilities, for he who does not realize his own responsibilities can hardly appraise the reprehensibilities of others. Do not select men for such work merely on the strength of your first impressions of your affection or good faith; for as a matter of fact; the pretensions of a good many who are really devoid of honesty and good breeding may cheat even the intelligence of rulers. Selection should be made after due probation which should be the test of righteousness. In making direct appointments from people, see to it that those selected possess influence with the people and who enjoy the reputation of being honest; for such selection is agreeable to God and the ruler. For every department of administration, let there be a head, whom no trying task might cause worry and no pressure of work annoy.
And remember that every weakness of any one among your establishment and scribe which you may overlook will be written down against you in your scroll of deeds.
Trade and Industry
Adopt useful schemes placed before those engaged in trade and industry and help them with wise counsels. Some of them live in towns, and some move from place to place with their wares and tools and earn their living by manual labor. Trade and Industry are sources of profit to the State. While the general public is not inclined to bear the strain, those engaged in these professions take the trouble to collect commodities from far and near, from land and from across the sea, and from mountains and forests and naturally derive benefits.
It is this class of peace loving people from whom no disturbance need be feared. They love peace and order; indeed they are incapable of creating disorder. Visit every part of the country and establish personal contact with this class, and inquire into their condition. But bear in mind that a good many of them are intensely greedy and are inured to bad dealings. They hoard grain and try to sell it at a high price; and this is most harmful to the public. It is a blot on the name of the ruler not to fight this evil. Prevent them from hoarding; for the Prophet of God -Peace be upon him - had prohibited it. And see to it that trade is carried on with the utmost ease, that the scales are evenly held and that prices are so fixed that neither the seller nor the buyer is put to a loss. And if inspite of your warning, should anyone go against your commands and commit the crime of hoarding, then deal him appropriately with severe punishment.
The Poor
Beware! Fear God when dealing with the problem of the poor who have non to patronize, who are forlorn, indigent and helpless and are greatly torn in mind -victims of the vicissitudes of Time. Among them there are some who do not question their lot in life not withstanding their misery, do not go about abegging. For God's sake, safeguard their rights; for on you rests the responsibility of protection. Assign for their uplift a portion of the state exchequer (Baitul-mal), wherever they may be, whether close at hand or far away from you. The rights of the two should be equal in your eye. Do not let any preoccupation slip them from your mind; for no excuse whatsoever for the disregard of their rights will be acceptable to God. Do not treat their interests as of less importance than your own, and never keep them outside the purview of your important considerations, and mark the persons who look down upon them and of whose conditions they keep you in ignorance.
Select from among your officers such men as are meek and God fearing who can keep you properly informed of the condition of the poor. Make such provision for these poor people as shall not oblige you to offer an excuse before God on the Day of Judgment; for, it is this section of the people more than any other which deserves benevolent treatment. Seek your reward from God by giving to each of them what is due to him and enjoin on yourself as a sacred duty the task of meting the needs of such aged among them as have no independent means of livelihood and are averse to seek alms. And it is the discharge of this duty that usually proves very trying for ruler, but is very welcome to societies which are gifted with foresight. It is only such societies or nations who truly carry out with equanimity their covenant with God to discharge their duty to the poor.
Open Conferences
Meet the oppressed and the lowly periodically in an open conference and, conscious of the divine presence there, have a heart-to-heart talk with them, and let none from your armed guard or civil officers or members of the police or the Intelligence Department be by your side, so that the representatives of the poor might state their grievances fearlessly and without reserve. For I have the Prophet of God saying that no nation or society will occupy a high position in which the strong do not discharge their duty to the weak. Bear with composure any strong language which they may use, and do not get annoyed if they cannot state their case lucidly, even so, God will open you his door of blessings and rewards. Whatever you can give to them, give it ungrudgingly, and whatever you cannot afford to give, make that clear to them in utmost sincerity.
There are certain things which call for prompt action. Accept the recommendations made by your officers for the redress of the grievances of the clerical staff. See to it that petitions or applications that are submitted for your consideration are brought to your notice the very day they are submitted, however much your officers might try to intercede them. Dispose off the day's work that very day, for the coming day will bring with it its own tasks.
Communion with God
And do not forget to set apart the best of your time for communion with God, although every moment of yours is for Him only, provided it is spend sincerely in the service of your people. The special time that you give to prayer in the strict religious sense is to be devoted to the performances of the prescribed daily prayers. Keep yourself engaged in these prayers both in the day and in the night, and to gain perfect communion, do not as far as possible, let your prayers grow tiresome. And when you lead in congregational prayer, do not let your prayer be so lengthy as to cause discomfort to the congregation or raise in them the feeling of dislike for it or liquidate its effect: for in the congregation there may be invalids and also those who have to attend pressing affairs of their own.
When I had asked of the Prophet of God on receiving an order to proceed to Yaman, how I should lead the people there in prayer, he said -perform your prayers even as the weakest among you would do; and set an example of consideration to the faithful.
Aloofness not desirable
Alongside of the observance of all that I have said above bear one thing in mind. Never for any length of time keep yourself aloof from the people, for to do so is to keep oneself ignorant of their affairs. It develops in the ruler a wrong perspective and renders him unable to distinguish between what is important and what is not, between right and wrong, and between truth and falsehood. The ruler is after all human; and he cannot form a correct view of anything which is out of sight. There is no distinctive sign attached to truth which may enable one to distinguish between the different varieties of truth and falsehood. The fact is that you must be one of two things. Either you are just or unjust. If you are just, then you will not keep yourself away from the people, but will listen to them and meet their requirements. On the other hand, it you are unjust, the people themselves will keep way from you. What virtue is there in your keeping aloof? At all events aloofness is not desirable especially when it is your duty to attend to the needs of the people. Complaints of oppression by your officers or petitions for justice should not prove irksome to you.
Make this clear to yourself that those immediately about and around you will like to exploit their position to covet what belongs to others and commit acts of injustice. Suppress such a tendency in them. Make a rule of your conduct never to give even a small piece of land to any of your relations. That will prevent them from causing harm to the interests of others and save you from courting the disapprobation of God andMan.
Deal justice squarely regardless of the fact whether one is a relation or not. If any of your relations or companions violates the law, mete out the punishment prescribed by law however painful it might be to you personally; for it will be all to the good of the State. If at any time people suspect, that you have been unjust to them in any respect disclose your mind to them and remove their suspicions. In this way, your mind will get attuned to the sense of justice and people will begin to love you. It will also fulfill your wish that you should enjoy their confidence.
Peace and Treaties
Bear in mind that you do not throw away the offer of peace which your enemy may himself make. Accept it, for, that will please God. Peace is a source of comfort to the army; it reduces your worries and promotes order in the State. But Beware! Be on your guard when the peace is signed; for, certain types of enemies propose terms of peace just to lull you into a sense of security only to attack you again when you are off your guard. So you should exercise the utmost vigilance on your part, and place no undue faith in their protestations. But, if under the peace treaty you have accepted any obligations, discharge those obligations scrupulously. It is a trust and must be faithfully upheld and whenever you have promised anything, keep it with all the strength that you command, for whatever differences of opinion might exist on other matters, there is nothing so noble as the fulfillment of a promise. This is recognized even among non-Muslims, for they know the dire consequences which follow from the breaking of covenants. So never make excuses in discharging your responsibilities and never break a promise, nor cheat your enemy. For, breach of promise is an act against God, and none except the positively wicked acts against God
Indeed divine promises are a blessing spread over all mankind. The promise of God is a refuge sought after even by the most powerful on earth; for there is no risk of being cheated. So, do not make any promise from which you may afterwards offer excuses to retract; nor do you go back upon what you have confirmed to abide by; nor do you break it, however galling it may at first prove to be. For, it is far better to wait in patience for wholesome results to follow than to break it out of any apprehensions.
Beware! Abstain from shedding blood without a valid cause. There is nothing more harmful than this which brings about one's ruin. The blood that is willfully shed shortens the life of a state. On the Day of Judgment it is this crime for which one will have to answer first. So, beware! Do not wish to build the strength of your state on blood; for, it is this blood which ultimately weakens the state and passes it on to other hands. Before me and my God no excuse for willful killing can be entertained.
Murder is a crime which is punishable by death. If on any accord the corporal punishment dealt by the state for any lesser crime results in the death of the guilty, let not the prestige of the stage stand in any way of the deceased relations claiming blood money.
Last Instructions
Do not make haste to do a thing before its time, nor put it off when the right moment arrives. Do not insist on doing a wrong thing, nor show slackness in rectifying a wrong thing. Perform everything in its proper time, and let everything occupy its proper place. When the people as a whole agree upon a thing, do not impose your own view on them and do not neglect to discharge the responsibility that rests on you in consequence. For, the eyes of the people will be on you and you are answerable for whatever you do to them. The slightest dereliction of duty will bring its own retribution. Keep your anger under control and keep your hands and tongue in check whenever you fall into anger, try to restrain yourself or else you will simply increase your worries.
It is imperative on you to study carefully the principles which have inspired just and good rulers who have gone before you. Give close thought to the example of our prophet (peace be upon him), his traditions, and the commandments of the Book of God and whatever you might have assimilated from my own way of dealing with things. Endeavor to the best of your ability to carry out the instructions which I have given you here and which you have solemnly undertaken to follow. By means of this order, I enjoin on you not to succumb to the prompting of your own heart or to turn away from the discharge of duties entrusted to you.
I seek the refuge of the might of the Almighty and of His limitless sphere of blessings, and invite you to pray with me that He may give us together the grace willingly to surrender our will to His will, and to enable us to acquit ourselves before Him and His creation; so that mankind might cherish our memory and our work survive. I seek of God the culmination of his blessings and pray that He may grant you and me His grace and the honor of martyrdom in His cause. Verily, we have to return to Him. I invoke His blessings on the Prophet of God and his pure progeny.